'AH 


•Bsnoms 


9a3"** 

....iiVA 


AKh'  33   1313 


A  CONTRIBUTION 
.    TO  A  BIBLIOGRAPHY  OF 


& 


HENRI  BERGSON 


V 


COLUMBIA  UNIVERSITY  PRESS 
1913 

Price  25  cents  net 


BIBLIOGRAPHY 

OF 

HENRI    BERGSON 


COLUMBIA 

UNIVERSITY  PRESS 

SALES  AGENTS 

New  York: 

LEMCKE  &  BUECHNER 

30-32  West  27th  Street 

London: 
HENRY  FROWDE 
Amen  Corner,  E.C. 

Toronto: 

HENRY  FROWDE 

25  Richmond  Street,  W. 


Columbia  TlmiversttE  in  tbe  Cttg  of  "Hew  tforfe 
XTbe  Xibrarp 


A  CONTRIBUTION 

TO  A  BIBLIOGRAPHY  OF 

HENRI  BERGSON 


COLUMBIA  UNIVERSITY  PRESS 
1913 


13' 


Copyright,  1913 
By  Columbia  University  Press 

Printed  from  type,  January,  1913 


CONTENTS 

PAGE 

Preface vii 

Introduction ix 

Part  I. — Works  by  Bergson  .....  i 
Part  II. — Works  about  Bergson  .  .  .  .16 
Index 53 


v 

25353 L 


PREFACE 

The  purpose  of  the  present  bibliography  is  to  show  the  wide- 
spread and  varied  interest  in  Professor  Bergson's  philosophy, 
and  completeness  rather  than  selection  has  therefore  been  the 
aim  of  the  compilers.  No  attempt  has  been  made  to  list  the 
newspaper  literature  of  the  subject,  and  short  book  reviews  have 
generally  been  omitted,  but  all  other  literature,  either  book  or 
periodical,  which  has  come  to  the  compilers'  attention  has  been 
included.  Titles  which  have  been  included  without  examination 
are  starred.  The  bibliography  includes  90  books  and  articles 
by  Professor  Bergson  (including  translations  of  his  works)  and 
417  books  and  articles  about  him.  These  417  items  represent  11 
different  languages  divided  as  follows: — French  170,  English  159, 
German  40,  Italian  19,  Polish  5,  Dutch  3,  Spanish  3,  Roumanian 
2,  Swedish  2,  Russian  2,  Hungarian  1 .  Translations  of  Professor 
Bergson's  principal  works  are  now  available  in  many  languages. 
So  far  the  one  most  widely  translated  is  V Introduction  &  la 
Metaphysique  which  is  now  accessible  in  the  English,  German, 
Italian,  Swedish,  Hungarian,  Polish,  and  Russian  languages. 

The  bibliography  has  been  compiled  by  members  of  the  staff 
of  the  University  Library  under  the  direction  of  Miss  Isadore  G. 
Mudge,  the  Reference  Librarian,  but  thanks  for  special  services 
are  due  to  many  outside  the  library  staff  who  have  given  valu- 
able aid.  Acknowledgment  of  such  indebtedness  is  due  especially 
to  Professor  John  Dewey  for  the  Introduction  to  the  present 
volume,  to  Professor  Wendell  T.  Bush  for  the  descriptive  and 
critical  notes  included  in  Part  I,  to  Mrs.  E.  M.  Sait  for  the 
preparation  of  a  preliminary  list  for  Part  I,  to  Dr.  Benjamin 

vii 


Rand  of  Harvard  University  for  criticism  of  the  preliminary 
bibliography  and  for  the  suggestion  of  additional  titles,  to  Dr. 
Lars  Aksel  Anderson,  Librarian  of  the  University  of  Upsala,  for 
information  about  Swedish  titles,  and  to  Dr.  Richard  Fick, 
Director  of  the  Prussian  Gesamt-Katalog,  for  information  about 
German  translations. 

W.  Dawson  Johnston, 

University  Librarian. 


Vlll 


INTRODUCTION 

Henri  Bergson' s  books  are  fortunately  now  accessible  to  the 
public  in  an  English  dress.     For  this  reason  and  because  it 
seems  desirable  to  have  Professor  Bergson  speak  for  himself  as 
to  his  fundamental  doctrines,  no  synopses  of  the  books  are  given 
in  the  following  pages.     A  few  words — derived  as  far  as  possible 
from  Mr.  Bergson  himself- — are,  however,  prefixed  regarding  the 
more  general  features  of  his  philosophy.     And  first  as  to  Intu- 
ition, an  idea  that  plays,  as  everybody  knows,  a  large  r61e  in  his 
conception  of  philosophic  method.     It  happens  that  in  English 
thought  the  asssociations  that  cluster  about  the  word  are  mainly 
derived  from  Platonic  transcendentalism,  and  from  the  theories 
of  the  Scotch  School  and  the  super-scientific,  regarding  an  organ 
of  knowledge  that  is  independent   of  experience  and  superior 
to  the  sciences.     These  associations  with  the  a  priori  are  quite 
foreign  to  the  use  of  the  term  in  the  Bergsonian  philosophy;  and 
no  one  has  deprecated  their  introduction  into  it  more  vigorously 
than  Professor  Bergson  himself.     He  has  said :  ' '  The  method  that 
I  propose  does  not  consist  in  extracting  from  reality  a  simple 
concept  in  order  that  it  may  then  be  submitted  to  dialectic 
elaboration.      On  the  contrary,  my  method  demands  uninter- 
rupted contact  with  reality.     It  consists  in  following  reality  in 
all  its  sinuosities.     It  demands  that  our  faculties  of  observation 
even  stretch  themselves  at  times  to  surpass  themselves.  It  is  made 
of  corrections,  retouchings,  gradual  complications.     It  aspires  to 
constitute  metaphysics  as  certain  and  as  universally  recognized 
as  any  of  the  other  sciences. "     And  again  he  has  said:  "Let  us 
accept  science  in  all  its  concrete  complexity;  then  let  us  recom- 

ix 


mence,  with  this  new  science  as  its  material,  a  task  like  that  which 
ancient  metaphysicians  undertook  with  the  simpler  science  of 
their  day.  We  must  break  the  mathematical  framework,  take 
account  of  biological,  psychological  and  sociological  sciences, 
and  upon  this  larger  base  erect  a  metaphysics  capable  of  going 
higher  and  higher  by  means  of  the  continuous,  progressive  and 
organized  effort  of  all  philosphers  who  are  associated  in  the  same 
respect  for  experience. " 

Again  he  says:  "  I  have  never  claimed  that  intelligence  should 
be  replaced  by  something  else,  or  that  instinct  should  be  pre- 
ferred to  it.  I  have  simply  tried  to  show  that  when  we  leave  the 
realm  of  mathematical  and  physical  objects  to  enter  that  of  life 
and  consciousness,  we  need  to  appeal  to  a  certain  sense  of  life 
that  encroaches  upon  pure  understanding  and  that  has  its  origin 
in  the  same  vital  impetus  as  instinct— although,  strictly  speaking, 
instinct  is  something  wholly  different."  Finally:  "There  is 
nothing  mysterious  in  this  faculty.  Every  one  of  us  has  had 
occasion  to  exercise  it  to  a  certain  extent.  Any  one  of  us,  for 
example,  who  has  attempted  literary  composition,  knows  that 
after  the  subject  has  long  been  studied,  materials  collected  and 
notes  made,  something  is  still  needed  to  set  up  the  work  of 
composition  itself;  namely,  an  effort,  often  quite  painful,  to 
place  ourselves  at  the  very  heart  of  the  subject,  to  seek  there,  as 
deeply  as  possible,  an  impulse  after  which  we  need  only  let  our- 
selves go.  .  .  .  Metaphysical  intuition  seems  to  be  something 
of  the  same  kind.  The  sum  of  observations  and  experiments 
gathered  together  by  physical  science  corresponds  in  metaphysics 
to  the  documents  and  notes  of  literary  composition.  We  do 
not  secure  an  intuition  of  reality — that  is,  an  intellectual  sym- 
pathy with  the  most  intimate  part  of  it — unless  we  have  won  its 
confidence  by  long  companionship  with  its  outer  manifestations.  " 

Turning  from  method  to  subject-matter,  the  following  passage 
seems  to  be  highly  significant  for  an  understanding  of  Bergson's 
treatment  of  the  two  problems  which  form  the  themes  of  his 
Matter  and  Memory  and  his  Creative  Evolution — a  passage  com- 

x 


posed,  it  should  be  added,  in  1901,  namely,  after  the  publica- 
tion of  the  former  book  and  considerably  prior  to  the  appearance 
of  the  latter:     "I  cannot  envisage  general  evolution  and  the 
progress  of  life  in  the  totality  of  the  organic  world,  the  coordina- 
tion and  subordination  of  vital  organs  to  one  another  in  a  single 
living   being,   the   relations   which   physiology  and  psychology 
seem  to  have  established  between  cerebral  activity  and  thought 
in  man,  without  arriving  at  the  conclusion  that  life  is  an  immense 
effort  put  forth  by  thought  to  obtain  from  matter  something  that 
matter  is  unwilling  to  give.     Matter  is  inert;  it  is  the  seat  of 
necessity ;  it  proceeds  mechanically.     It  seems  as  if  thought  seeks 
to  profit  by  this  mechanical  attitude  of  matter,  to  utilize  it  for 
actions;  and  thus  to  convert  into  contingent  movements  in  space 
and  unforeseeable  events  in  time  all  the  creative  energy  that 
thought  carries  within  itself — at  least  all  that  is  capable  of  being 
brought  into  play  and  externalized.     Cunningly  and  laboriously 
it  piles  complication  on  complication  in  order  to  make  liberty  out 
of  necessity,  to  arrange  a  matter  so  subtle,  so  mobile,  that,  by  a 
veritable  physical  paradox  and  grace  to  an  effort  which  can  not 
long  endure,  liberty  may  hold  itself  in  equilibrium  on  this  very 
mobility.     But  thought  is  caught  in  the  net.     The  vortex  upon 
which  it  has  placed  itself  seizes  and  holds  it.     It  becomes  a 
prisoner  of  the  mechanisms  which  it  has  climbed.     Automatism 
captures  it,  and  by  an  inevitable  forgetfulness  of  the  end  that  it 
had  set  for  itself,  life,  which  should  be  only  a  means  for  a  higher 
end,  consumes  itself  in  the  effort  at  simple  self-conservation. 
From  the  humblest  of  organic  beings  to  the  higher  vertebrates 
which  just  antecede  man  we  are  watching  an  endeavor  always 
missing  success,  always  reundertaken  with  an  increasingly  wise 
art.     Man  has  triumphed — but  with  difficulty  and  so  partially 
that  it  needs  only  a  moment  of  relaxation  or  inattention  for 
automatism  to  recapture  him.     Nevertheless  he  has  triumphed, 
thanks  to  that  marvellous  mechanism,  the  human  brain.     The 
superiority  of  this  instrument  seems  to  me  to  depend  wholly 
upon  the  indefinite  latitude  it  permits  of  surmounting  the  mechan- 

xi 


isms  that  have  given  pause  to  other  animals.  It  forms,  not  once 
for  all  but  continuously,  motor  habitudes  whose  exercise  it 
delegates  to  lower  centres.  ...  In  a  general  way,  the  superi- 
ority of  our  brain  resides  in  the  power  of  liberation  which  it 
gives  us  in  regard  to  bodily  automatisms  through  permitting  us 
incessantly  to  form  new  habits  which  absorb  old  ones  or  hold 
them  in  subordination.  In  this  sense  there  is  nothing  to  be 
found  in  the  brain  corresponding  to  the  operation  of  thought  in 
its  strict  sense.  Nevertheless  it  is  the  brain  that  has  rendered 
human  thought  possible.  Without  it  the  higher  powers  of 
thought  could  not  turn  toward  the  material  world  without  being 
captured  by  automatism  and  drowned  in  unconsciousness." 

No  one  needs  to  be  told  how  thoroughly  Professor  Bergson  has 
exemplified  in  his  own  method  of  thinking  and  writing  the 
intellectual  sympathy  which  he  has  so  well  described — how  after 
gathering  together  and  absorbing  all  available  scientific  material 
he  has  found  a  point  of  synoptic  vision  from  which  to  envisage 
the  multiplicity  of  details.  Nor  does  any  one  who  has  followed 
the  development  of  contemporary  philosophy  need  to  be  reminded 
that  in  so  doing  Professor  Bergson  has,  in  his  successive  books, 
placed  in  a  new  light  the  old  and  oft  shop-worn  questions  of  the 
nature  of  human  intelligence,  its  relation  to  the  brain  and  to 
matter  and  to  evolution.  Perhaps  only  the  more  professional 
students  of  philosophy  can  adequately  realize  the  debt  under 
which  he  has  placed  all  workers  in  this  field  by  centering  atten- 
tion in  such  an  illuminating  and  rewarding  way  upon  the  nature 
of  time,  and  the  fundamental  character  of  the  problem  of  time 
for  theories  of  reality,  of  mental  life,  of  freedom  and  evolution. 
No  philosophic  problem  will  ever  exhibit  just  the  same  face 
and  aspect  that  it  presented  before  Professor  Bergson  invited 
us  to  look  at  it  in  its  connexions  with  duration  as  a  real  and 
fundamental  fact. 

It  is  the  object  of  the  following  bibliographical  pages  to  help  to 
bring  an  even  wider  audience  in  touch  with  the  vital  influences  that 
radiate  from  Professor  Bergson's  thought.     They  should  facilitate 

xii 


a  more  intelligent  understanding  of  his  lectures,  and  enable  those 
interested  to  follow  up,  by  more  leisurely  reading,  the  desire  for 
further  knowledge  that  will  spring  from  them.  It  has  been  my 
privilege,  in  these  prefatory  words,  to  indicate  the  place  of  this 
Bibliography  in  the  intellectual  and  personal  welcome  that 
Columbia  University  in  general  and  its  Department  of  Philoso- 
phy in  particular  extends  to  our  colleague  for  the  time  being, 
Professor  Henri  Bergson. 

John  Dewey. 
Columbia  University, 
December  12,  1912. 


xm 


PART  I 

WORKS  BY  BERGSON 

Arranged  chronologically  by  date  of  first  publication  except  that 

translations  are  placed  immediately  after  the  original 

work.     Titles  marked  with  an  (*)  represent 

material  which  has  not  been  seen 

by  the  compilers 

La  specialite.  Discours  prononce  par  M.  Bergson  ...  a  la 
distribution  des  prix  du  Lycee  d'Angers,  le  3  aout  1882. 
Angers,  Imprimerie  Lachese  et  Dolbeau,  1882.     16  p.*         1 

Extraits  de  Lucrece:  avec  une  commentaire  des  notes  et  une 
etude  sur  la  po£sie,  la  philosophic,  la  physique,  le  texte  et  la 
langue  de  Lucrece.     Paris,  Delagrave,  1884.     159  p.  2 

Eighth  Edition  [1912]. 

De  la  simulation  inconsciente  dans  l'etat  d'hypnotisme.  Revue 
philosophigiie,  22:  525-31,  November  1886.  3 

The  hypnotised  subject,  unable  to  disobey  instructions,  resorts  to  any 
possible  device  in  order  to  obey,  with  the  result  that  he  seems  expert  in 
deception,  but  the  deception  is  unconscious. 

Quid  Aristoteles  de  loco  senserit.  Paris,  Felix  Alcan,  1889. 
82  p.*  Thesis,  University  de  Paris,  Faculte  des  Lettres, 
1889-90.  3a 

Essai  sur  les  donnees  immediates  de  la  conscience.  Paris, 
Felix  Alcan,  1889.     viii,  185  p.  4 

Seventh  edition,  1909. 

TRANSLATIONS 

Time  and  free  will.  An  essay  on  the  immediate  data  of 
consciousness.      Authorized  translation  by  F.  L.  Pogson. 

1 


London,    Swan    Sonnenschein    &   co.,    Ltd.;  New    York, 

The    Macmillan    co.,    1910.      xxiii,    252    p.  (Library   of 

philosophy) .  5 
Second  edition,  191 2. 

Zeit  und  freiheit.  Eine  abhandlungen  uber  die  unmittel- 
baren  bewusstseinstatsachen.  Berechtigte  iibersetzung. 
Jena,    E.  Diederichs,  1911.      189  p.*  6 

Vremia  i  svoboda  voli.  S  prilozheniem  traktata  togo  zhe 
avtora  Vvedenie  v  metafiziku.  [Trans,  by  S.  Hessen  and 
M.  Grunwald.]  St.  Petersburg,  Russkaia  mysl',  1912.  238 
p.*  6a 

REVIEWS 

Of  the  original  work 

Rivista  italiana  di  filosofia,  5:248-49,  March  1890  (Luigi  Ferri);  Revue 
philosophique,  29:  519-38,  May  1890  (L.  Levy-Bruhl) ;  Revue  critique,  n. 
s->  30:  5i7-i9»  29  December  1890  (Lucien  Herr);  Mind,  15:292-93,  April 
1890  (T.  Whittaker);  Speaker  (London),  1:520,  10  May  1890  (G.  F. 
Stout);  Annee  philosophique,  1800,  227-28,  1891. 

Of  the  English  translation 

Spectator,  105:465-66,  24  September  1910;  Saturday  review,  110:430,  1 
October  1910;  Athenaeum,  2:483-84,  22  October  1910;  Nation  (N.  Y.), 
91:499-500,  24  November  1910;  Current  literature,  50:518-20,  May 
191 1 ;  Mind,  n.  s.,  20:357-78,  July  191 1  (David  Balsillie);  Hibbert 
journal,  9:895-907,  July  191 1  (J.  H.  Muirhead);  New  York  Times  review 
of  books,  16:503,  20  August  191 1 ;  Outlook  (N.  F.),  99:  819-26,  2  Decem- 
ber 191 1  (Theodore  Roosevelt);  Church  quarterly  review,  74:126-42, 
April  19 12  (William  Brown). 

Le  bon  sens  et  les  etudes  classiques.  Discours  prononce  a 
la  distribution  des  prix  du  Concours  general  des  lycees  et 
colleges,  1895.  Distribution  des  prix  du  Concours  general, 
Paris,  Delalain.     1895.*  7 

Memoire  et  reconnaissance.  Revue  philosophique,  41:225-48, 
380-99,  March-April  1896. 

Republished  in  Matie're  et  memoire.  8 

2 


Perception  et  matiere.      Reinie   de   metaphysique    et   de   morale, 

4:257-77.  MaY  l8(A  9 

Republished  in  Mature  et  memoire. 
Matiere  et  memoire:   essai  sur  la  relation  du  corps  avec  l'esprit. 
Paris,  Felix  Mean,  1896.     iii,  279  p.  10 

Sixth  edition,  19 10. 

TRANSLATIONS 

Materie  und  gedachtnis.  Essays  zur  beziehung  zwischen 
korper  und  geist.  Autorisierte  u.v.  verfasser  selbst  durch- 
gesehene  ubertragung,  m.  einfuhrung  von  W.  Windelband. 
Jena,  E.  Diederichs,  1908.     xvi,  264  p.*  « 

Matter  and  memory.  Authorized  translation  by  Nancy 
Margaret  Paul  and  W.  Scott  Palmer.  London,  Swan 
Sonnenschein  &  CO.;  New  York,  The  Macmillan  CO.,  191 1. 
xx,  359  p.     (Library  of  philosophy.)  12 

REVIEWS 

Of  the  original  work 

Revue  de  metaphysique,  5:353-«9,  May  1897  (Victor  Delbos);  Annie 
philosophise,  1896,  7: 190-92,  1897  (F.  Pillon);  Revue  philosophtque,  44: 
183-99,  August  1897  (Gustave  Belot);  Mind,  12:  572-73.  October  1897 
(S.  Alexander);  Zeitschrift  filr  philosophie,  n.  s.,  113:295-99,  December 
1898  (Th.  Ziehen);  Revue  de  metaphysique,  10:225-43. 

Of  the  German  translation 

Archiv  fur  die  gesamte  psychologie  (Literaturbericht) ,  15:13-15!  x909  (F. 
Braun);  Zeitschrift  fur  psychologie,  56:126-29,  May  1910  (Richard 
Muller-Freienfels) ;  Literarisches  centralblatt  fur  Deutschland,  61:  917-18, 
9  July  1 9 1  o ;  Vierteljahrschrift  fur  wissenschaftliche  philosophie ,  34 :  353~57 , 
September  1910  (Richard  Fritzsche):  Allgemeine  literaturblatt,  p.  298, 
1910  (A.  Muller);  Zeitschrift  filr  pathopsychologie,  1:  603-39,  1912. 

Of  the  English  translation 

Current  literature,  50:518-20,  May  1911;  Spectator,  106:689-90,  6  May 
191 1 ;  Nation  (N.  Y.),  92:648-49,  29  June  191 1;  Hibbert  journal,  9: 
895-907,  July  191 1  (J.  H.  Muirhead);  New  York  Times  review  of  books, 
16:503,  20  August  1911;  International  journal  of  ethics,  22:101-07, 
October  191 1  (A.  E.  Taylor);  Church  quarterly  review,  74:  126-42,  April 
19 1 2  (W.  Brown). 

3 


Revue  critique:  Principes  de  metaphysique  et  de  psychologie, 
par  Paul  Janet.  Revue  philosophique,  44:525-51,  Novem- 
ber 1897.  13 

Le  rire.  Revue  de  Paris,  1:512-44,  759-9^.  2:146-79,  1-15 
February-i   March  1900.  14 

Le  rire:  cssai  sur  la  signification  du  comique.  Paris,  Felix 
Alcan,  1900.     vii,  204  p.  15 

First  published  in  the  Revue  de  Paris,  1:512-44,  759~9°; 
2: 146-79,  February-March  1900. 
Seventh  edition,  191 1. 

TRANSLATIONS 

Smiech.  Studyum  o  komicie.  Wiedza  i  zycie;  zagadnienia 
z  pradu  wspofczesnego  w  dziedzinie  wiedzy,  sztuki  i  zycia 
spotecznego.     ser.  2,  vol.  n,  1902.*  15a 

Skrattet.  En  undersokning  av  komikens  vasen.  Till 
svenska  av  Algot  Ruhe.     Stockholm,  1910.     172  p.*  16 

Laughter.  An  essay  on  the  meaning  of  the  comic.  Author- 
ized translation  by  Cloudesley  Brereton  and  Fred.  Rothwell. 
New  York,  The  Macmillan  co.,  191 1.     vii,  200  p.  17 

REVIEWS 

Of  the  original  work 

Wiener  Zeitung  no.  158,  1900;  Deutsche  litteraturzeitung,  22:13-14,  5  Jan- 
uary 1901;  Psychological  review,  8:98-99,  January  1901  (J.  H.  Tufts); 
Annee  philosophique,  iqoo,  11 :  135-38,  1901  (F.  Pillon) ;  Revue  de  metaphy- 
sique, 9:224-36,  March  1901  (D.  Parodi);  Zeitschrift  fur  philosophic  n.  s., 
123:215-16,  1903  (Ziehen);  Nation  (London).  4:348-49,  28  November 
1908. 

Of  the  English  translation 

American  journal  of  psychology,  23:  146-47,  January  1912  (E.  B.  Titche- 
ner);  Living  age,  272:  315-17;  American  journal  of  psychology,  23:342, 
April  1912;  Edinburgh  review,  215:  383-404,  April  1912;  Journal  of  phil- 
osophy, 9: 303-05,  23  May  1912  (H.  M.  Kallen);  North  American  review, 
195:859-61,  June  1912;  Dublin. review,  151:181-84,  July  1912. 

4 


Notes  sur  les  origines  psychologiques  de  notre  croyance  a  la  loi 
de     causalite.      Bihliotheque  du   congrcs    international    de 

philosophic,  1900,  p.  1-15.  18 

Belief  in  the  law  of  causality  is  based  upon  the  co-ordination  of  our  tac- 
tile impressions  with  our  visual  impressions.  The  continuity  of  visual 
into  tactile  impressions  generates  motor  habits  which  are  tendencies  to 
action.  The  paper  was  read  at  the  International  Congress  of  Philosophy 
at  Paris  in  1900;  for  an  abstract  of  it  and  of  the  discussion  that  followed 
it  see  the  Revue  de  metaphysique  et  de  morale,  8: 655-60,  September  1900. 

Le  reve.  Conference  faite  a.  l'lnstitut  psychologique  le  26 
mars  1901 .  Bulletin  de  VInstitut  psychologique  international, 
1:103-22,  May  1 901;  Revue  scientifique,  4th  series,  15: 
705-13,  June  1 90 1.  Reported  in  condensed  form  in  the 
Revue  de  philosophic  1 1486-89,  April  1901.  19 

The  mechanism  of  dreams  is  like  that  of  normal  perceptions.  There  are 
sense  impressions  and  memories  that  give  them  form  and  precision.  But 
the  sleeper,  unlike  the  worker,  is  relaxed  from  the  attitude  of  control. 
To  sleep  is  to  be  indifferent,  to  attempt  nothing. 

Le  parallelisme  psycho-physique  et  la  metaphysique  positive. 
Bulletin  de  la  Societe  francaise  de  philosophic,  i:2>3-7l> 
June  1901.  20 

A  discussion  by  members  of  the  French  Philosophical  Society  of  M. 
Bergson's  theses  on  the  subject  of  psychophysical  parallelism.  An  ex- 
cellent introduction  to  what  is  most  characteristic  in  M.  Bergson's 
philosophy. 

L'Effort  intellectuel.  Revtie  philosophique,  53:1-27,  January 
1902.  21 

An  analysis  of  the  mental  characteristic  of  intellectual  effort.  In  in- 
tellectual invention  or  creation  there  is  at  first  the  idea  of  something 
general  and  abstract,  which  has  to  be  replaced  by  distinct  images  of  de- 
tail. Real  thinking  is  a  movement  back  and  forth  between  images  and 
their  meanings.  In  the  movement  from  the  plane  of  the  schema  to  the 
plane  of  the  concrete  image  there  is  a  series  of  mental  states  in  which 
various  images  try  to  occupy  the  schema  or  in  which  the  schema  progres- 
sively modifies  itself  into  distinct  images.  The  adaptation  of  schema  to 
image  and  of  image  to  schema  may  meet  with  resistance  from  either,  and 
in  proportion  as  this  produces  hesitation,  there  is  the  sense  of  obstacle 
and  effort  characteristic  of  intellectual  endeavor. 


La  volonte.  Discours  prononce"  a  la  distribution  des  prix  du 
Lyc£e  Voltaire,  July  1902.  Published  in  the  account  of  the 
distribution  of  prizes.     Imprimerie  Quelquejeu,  1902.*     22 

Rapport  sur  la  fondation  Carnot.  Seances  et  travaux  de  V Aca- 
demic des  sciences  morales  et  politiques  (Stance  du  6 
decembre  1902),  159:56-62,  January  1903.  23 

Introduction  a  la  metaphysique.     Revue  de  metaphysique  et  de 

morale,  11:1-36,  January  1903.  24 

Concepts  are  human  instruments  and,  as  dependable  instruments,  are 
necessarily  static.  Analysis  operates  upon  what  is  fictitiously  immutable 
and  gives  a  partial  and  selected  account  of  the  facts.  To  know  an  object 
as  it  really  is  we  must  not  substitute  for  it  a  composition  of  concepts  but 
apprehend  it  in  immediate  intuition.  Metaphysics,  the  disinterested 
curiosity  about  things  per  se,  must  use  this  method  which  alone  can  lay 
hold  of  what  is  fluctuating,  elusive  but  genuine. 

TRANSLATIONS 

Einfiihrung  in  die  metaphysik.  Autorisierte  iibertragung  v. 
M.  Susmann.     Jena,  E.  Diederichs,  1909.     58  p.*  25 

La  filosofia  dell'  intuizione :  introduzione  alia  metafisica  ed 
estratti  di  altre  opere,  a  cura  di  Giovanni  Papini.  Lanciano, 
R.  Carabba,  1908.     126  p.*  26 

Introduction  a  la  metaphysique.  Ungar.  v.  B.  Fogarasi, 
Budapest,  Politzer,  1910.     41  p.*  27 

Wstep  do  metafizyki.  Przef  ozyT*z  wste  pern ;  poprzedzif'  Kazi- 
mierz  Bteszyriski.  Krak6w,  Gebethner,  1910.  104  p.*  27a 
Intuition  och  intelligence.  Inledning  till  metafyseken.  Med 
ett  forord  ab  proffessor  Axel  Herrlin.  Till  svenska  av 
Algot  Ruhe.     Stockholm,   191 1.*  28 

Vremia  i  svoboda  voli.  S  prilozheniem  traktata  togo  zhe 
avtora  Vvedenie  v  metafiziku  [trans,  by  S.  Hessen  and  M. 
Grunwald].  St.  Petersburg,  Russkafa  my  si',  191 2.  238 
p.*  28a 

Introduction  to  metaphysics,  translated  by  T.  E.  Hulme. 
Authorized  edition  revised  by  the  author  with  additional 
material.    New  York,  G.  P.  Putnam's  Sons,  191 2.   92  p.    29 

6 


Introduction  to  a  new  philosophy.  Introduction  a  la 
m^taphysique,  [translated  into  English  by  Sidney  Littman]. 
Boston,  John  W.  Luce  &  CO.,  1912-     Io8  P-     Portrait.      30 

La  place  et  le  caractere  de  la  philosophic  dans  l'enseignement 
secondaire.  Bulletin  de  la  Societe  francaise  de  philosophie, 
3:25-55,  February  1903.  3* 

Rapport  sur  le  concours  pour  le  prix  Halphen  a  decerner  en  1903. 

Seances  et  travaux  de  VAcademie  des  sciences  morales  et 
politiques  (Seance  du  4  juillet  1903),  160:540-544,  Septem- 
ber-October 1903.  32 

Rapport  sur  le  concours  pour  le  prix  Halphen,  a  decerner  en  1903. 

Memoir es  de  VAcademie  des  sciences  morales  et  politiques 
(Seance  du  4  juillet  1903),  24:693-698,  1904.  34 

Vision  de  lueurs  dans  l'obscurite  par  les  sensitifs.  Bulletin  de 
VInstitut  general  psychologique,  4:30-31,  January-February 
1904.     Discussion.  35 

Les  radiations  N.  Bulletin  de  VInstitut  general  psychologique 
(Seance  du  28  decembre  1903),  4*25-32,  January-February 
1904.     Discussion.  3* 

Notice  sur  la  vie  et  les  ceuvres  de  M.  Felix  Ravaisson-Mollien. 

Seances  et  travaux  de  VAcademie  des  sciences  morales  et 
politiques  (Seance  des  20  et  27  fevrier  1904),  161:673-708, 
1904.  37 

Rapport  sur  la  fondation  Carnot.  Memoir  es  de  VAcademie  des 
sciences  morales  et  politiques  (Seance  du  24  mai  1902),  24: 
351-358,  1904-  38 

Rapport  sur  un  ouvrage  de  M.  Mortet:  Notes  sur  le  texte  des 
"  Institutiones "  de  Cassiodore,  par  M.  Victor  Mortet. 
Seances  et  travaux  de  VAcademie  des  sciences  morales  et 
politiques  (Seance  du  21  mai  1904),  162:485,  1  October 
1904.  39 

7 


Rapport  sur  un  ouvrage  de  Ruskin:  La  Bible  d'Amiens.  Pre- 
face et  traduction  de  M.  Marcel  Proust.  Seances  et  travaux 
de  V Academie  des  sciences  morales  et  politiques  (Seance  du 
28  mai  1 904) .     1 62 :  49 1  -92 ,  October  1 904 .  40 

Esquisse  d'un  systeme  de  psychologie  rationelle,  par  Emile  Lubac. 
Paris,  1904.     Preface  de  H.  Bergson.  41 

Le  paralogisme  psycho-physiologique.  Revue  de  metaphysique 
et  de  morale,  12:895-908,  November  1904.  42 

For  a  report  of  the  subsequent  discussion  see  idem  p.  1027- 
36.  A  lecture  before  the  philosophical  congress  at  Geneva, 
1904. 

The  thesis  of  psycho-physical  parallelism  is  entirely  metaphysical  in  origin 
and  has  descended  directly  from  Cartesianism.  It  is  the  metaphysic  of 
a  science  purely  mathematical  in  form,  of  science  as  it  was  conceived  in 
the  time  of  Descartes.  A  given  psychical  state  presumes  a  particular 
cerebral  state,  but  the  same  cerebral  state  may  correspond  to  several 
very  different  psychical  states,  those  namely  which  would  be  translated 
into  action  by  the  same  physical  movements. 

Les  courbes  respiratoires  pendant  l'hypnose.  Bulletin  de  Vln- 
stitut  general  psychologique,  1904,  5:155-164,  March-April 
1905.  43 

Esprit  etmatiere.  Bulletin  de  la  Societe  francaise  de  philosophic 
(Seance  du  22  d^cembre,  1904),  5:  73~101'  l9°5-  44 

Discussion  by  Binet,  Bergson  and  other  members  of  the 
Society.     Bergson,  p.  94-99- 

Rapport  sur  un  ouvrage  de  M.  Ossip  Lourie:  Le  bonheur  et 
l'intelligence.  Seances  et  travaux  de  V Academie  des  sciences 
morales  et  politiques  (Seance  du  ier  avril  1905),  164:114, 
July  1905.  45 

Correspondence  avec  M.  Gaston  Rageot  sur  sa  relation  d  W. 
James.     Revue  philosophique,  60:  229-231,  August  1905.     46 

Rapport  sur  le  concours  pour  le  prix  Bordin  (philosophic)  a 
d£cerner  en  1905:  Maine  de  Biran.  Seances  et  travaux  de 
V Academie  des  sciences  morales  et  politiques  (Seance  du  7 
novcmbre  1905),  165:152-162,  January  1906.  47 

8* 


Rapport  sur  un  ouvrage  de  M.  Jacques  Bardoux:  Essai  d'unc 
psychologie  de  l'Anglcterre  contemporaine:  les  crises 
belliqueuses.  Seances  et  travaux  de  V Academic  dcs  sciences 
morales  et  politiques  (Seance  du  10  fevrier  1906),  165:683-84, 
May  1906.  48 

Rapport  sur  un  ouvrage  de  M.  G.  H.  Luquet:  Idees  generates 
de  psychologic.  Seances  et  travaux  de  V  Academie  des 
sciences  morales  et  politiques  (Stance  du  24  novembre  1906), 
167:425-6,  1907.  49 

Rapport  sur  un  ouvrage  de  M.  Paul  Gaultier  (preface  de  M. 
Emile  Boutroux) :  Le  sens  de  l'art.  Seances  et  travaux 
de  V Academie  des  sciences  morales  et  politiques  (Seance  du 
24  novembre  1906),  167:  425~6,  March  1907.  50 

L'Idee  de  neant.  Revue  philosophique,  62 :  449-66,  November 
1906.  51 

Republished  as  part  of  chapter  iv  of  L' Evolution  creatrice. 
The  idea  of  nothing  is  a  pseudo  idea  and  any  problem  based  upon  it  is  a 
pseudo  problem.     Thus  the  question,  Why  does  anything  exist?  is  not 
a  legitimate  question  for  philosophy. 

Rapport  sur  le  concours  pour  le  prix  Bordin,  1905,  ay  ant  pour 
sujet  Maine  de  Biran.  Memoir es  de  V Academie  des  sciences 
morales  et  politiques,  25:  809-21,  1907.  52 

Notice  sur  la  vie  et  les  (Euvres  de  M.  Felix  Ravaisson-Mollien. 
Memoires  de  V Academie  des  sciences  morales  et  politiques, 
25:1-43,  1907.  53 

L'Evolution  creatrice.  Paris,  Felix  Mean,  1907.  viii,  403  p. 
Seventh  edition,  191 1.  54 

TRANSLATIONS 

Creative   evolution.       Authorized   translation    by    Arthur 
Mitchell.     N.  Y.,  Holt  and  CO.,  191X.     xv,  407  p.        55 

9 


Den  skapande  utvecklingen.  Om  livets  betydelse.  Till 
svenska  av  Algot  Ruhe.    Stockholm,  191 1.    345  p.*     56 

Schopferische  entwicklung.  Ubers,  v.  Gertr.  Dr.  Kantoro- 
wicz.     Jena,  E.  Diederichs,  1912.     373  p.*  57 

REVIEWS 

Of  the  original  work 

Revue  du  mois,  August  1907  (F.  Le  Dantec);  Revue  philosophique, 
64:  73-85,  July  1907  (Gaston  Ragot);  Revue  de  metaphysique,  15:620-70, 
September  1907  (Louis  Weber);  Review  of  theology  and  philosophy,  3:  249- 
51,  October  1907;  Hibbert  journal,  6:435-42,  January  1908  (G.  Tyrrell); 
Philosophical  review,  17:84-89,  January  1908  (B.  H.  Bode);  Revue  du 
clerge  francais,  January  1908  (Lenoble);  Annee  philosophique,  1907,  18: 
182-84,  !9o8  (F.  Pillon) ;  Bulletin  de  la  semaine,  6  May  1908  (M.  Legendre) ; 
Revue  thomiste,  16:137-63,  May-June,  1908  (T.  M.  Pegnes);  Rivista 
filosofica,  11 :  149-80,  March  1908  (B.  Varisco);  Zeitschrift  fur  philosophie, 
I5-  39-4I.  1908  (H.  Schoen);  Przeglad  filozoficzny,  1908;  Mind,  n.  s., 
17:402-08,  July  1908  (T.  Loveday);  Journal  of  philosophy,  5:603-12, 
28  October  1908  (A.  Mitchell);  Revue  de  philosophie,  13:  520-34,  Novem- 
ber 1908  (H.  Trouche);  International  journal  of  ethics,  22:462-67,  July 
1912  (M.  G.  Husband). 

Of  the  English  translation 

Athenaeum,  191 1,  1:411-12,  15  April  191 1;  Spectator,  106:689-90,  6 
May  191 1 ;  Saturday  review,  111:685-86,  3  June  191 1;  Nation  (N.  F.), 
92:648-49,  29  June  191 1 ;  Hibbert  journal,  9: 895-907,  July  191 1  (J.  H. 
Muirhead);  Mind,  n.  s.,  20:432-33  (J.Solomon);  Jewish  review,  July 
191 1  (A.  Wolf);  Nature,  87:475-77, 12  October  191 1  (J.  A.  T.);  New  York 
Times  review  of  books,  16:503,  20  August  191 1;  Bookman  (N.  Y.)t 
34:206,  October  191 1 ;  Outlook  (N.  Y.)t  99:819-26,  2  December  1911 
(T.Roosevelt);  Princeton  theological  review,  10:116-18,  January  1912 
(S.  A.  Martin);  Westminster  review,  177:343-47,  March  1912  (W. 
Blacklock);  American  journal  of  psychology,  23:33-35,  April  1912  (B.  H. 
Bode);  Church  quarterly  review,  74:126-42  (William  Brown);  Inter- 
national journal  of  ethics,  22:467-69,  July  1912  (A.  E.  Taylor). 

L'Evolution    creatrice.       Revue  du  mois,  4:351-54,  September 
1907.  58 

A  reply  to  Felix  Le  Dantec 's  eriticism  of  Evolution  creatrice. 

10 


A  propos  de  1'evolution  de  l'intelligence   geometrique.      Revue 
de  metaphysique  et  de  morale,  16:28-33,  January  1908.       59 

A  reply  to  M.  Borel.  The  following  passage  occurs:  "Nowhere  have  I 
claimed  that  we  should  '  replace  intelligence  by  something  else '  or  prefer 
instinct  to  it.  I  have  tried  to  show  merely  that  when  we  leave  the  region 
of  physical  and  mathematical  objects  to  that  of  life  and  consciousness, 
we  have  to  depend  on  a  certain  sense  of  living  which  has  its  origin  in  the 
same  vital  impulse  that  is  the  basis  of  instinct,  although  instinct,  strictly 
speaking,  is  something  quite  different." 

Sur  rinfluence  de  sa  philosophie   sur  les   eleves   des    lycees. 

Bulletin    de    la    Societe   Jrancaise  de  philosophie,    8:21-22, 

January  1908.  60 

[Lettre  sur  rinfluence  de  sa  philosophic]     Annee  psychologique, 

14:230-31,  1908.  61 

Rapport  sur  un  ouvrage  de  M.  Jacques  Bardoux:  Psychologie 
de  l'Angleterre  contemporaine :  les  crises  politiques;  pro- 
tectionisme  et  radicalisme.  Seances  et  travaux  de  V  Aca- 
demie des  sciences  morales  et  politiques  (Seance  du  29  juin 
1907),  169:105-107,  January  1908.  62 

Rapport  sur  un  ouvrage  de  M.  Merlant:  Senancour.  Seances  et 
travaux  de  V  Academie  des  sciences  morales  et  politiques 
(Seance  du  18  Janvier  1908),  169:720-21,  June  1908.        63 

Rapport  sur  un  ouvrage  de  M.  Bazaillas:  Musique  et  incon- 
science.  Seances  et  travaux  de  V Academie  des  sciences 
morales  et  politiques  (Seance  du  I  feVrier  1908),  169:719-20, 
June  1908.  64 

Rapport  sur  un  ouvrage  de  M.  Boirac :  La  psychologie  inconnue. 
Seances  et  travaux  de  V Academie  des  sciences  morales  et 
politiques  (Seance  du  28  mars  1908),  170:119-20,  July 
1908.  65 

Rapport  sur  un  ouvrage  de  M.Jean  Paul  Nayrac:  La  Fontaine. 
Seances  et  travaux  de  V Academie  des  sciences  morales  et 
politiques  (Seance  du  23  mai  1908),  170:  484,  September 
1908.  66 

11 


Rapport  sur  le  concours  pour  le  prix  Le  Dissez  de  Penanrun. 

Seances  et  travaux  de  VAcademie  des  sciences  morales  et 
politiques  (Seance  du  26  octobre  1907),  169:91-102,  January 
1908.  67 

Rapport  sur  un  ouvrage  de  M.  Georges  Dwelshauvers :  La 
synthese  mentale.  Seances  et  travaux  de  VAcademie  des 
sciences  morales  et  politiques  (Seance  du  20  juin  1908),  170: 
623-4,  November-December  1908.  68 

Vocabulaire  technique  et  critique  de  la  philosophie.  Bulletin 
de  la  Societe  frangaise  de  philosophie,  8:331-33,  341,  August 
1908.  69 

Contains  a  discussion  by  M.  Bergson  and  others  of  the 
terms  "immediat"  and  "  inconnaissable. " 

M.  Bergson  explains  that  with  regard  to  the  hypothesis  that  a  state  of 
mind  reflects  a  cerebral  phenomenon,  and  might  have  been  different  for  a 
brain  having  a  different  chemical  constitution :  ( 1 )  he  holds  this  view  to  be 
self-contradictory  (see  Le  Paralogisme  psychologique) ;  (2)  in  so  far  as 
it  is  intelligible  it  is  contradicted  by  the  facts  (Matter  and  Memory,  ch.  II 
and  III) :  it  implies  a  whole  metaphysic  whose  sources  it  is  easy  to  dis- 
cover (Creative  Evolution,  ch.  IV).  The  truth  is  that  the  role  of  the 
brain  is  to  assure  the  perfect  insertion  of  the  mind  in  its  present  environ- 
ment, through  elimination  of  the  useless.  The  constitution  of  the  brain 
will  explain  in  certain  cases  the  absence  of  impressions,  never  their  pres- 
ence. It  was  one  of  the  chief  purposes  of  Matter  and  Memory  and 
Creative  Evolution  to  refute  the  claim  that  consciousness  does  not  reach 
beyond  the  subjective  and  that  the  immediately  given  is  peculiar  to  the 
individual.  In  the  former  it  is  shown  that  the  objectivity  of  the  material 
thing  is  immanent  in  the  perception  of  it,  taking  this  in  its  primitive  and 
immediate  form.  In  the  latter  it  is  shown  that  immediate  intuition 
apprehends  the  essence  of  life  as  well  as  of  matter. 

Le  souvenir  du  present  et  la  fausse  reconnaissance.  Revue 
philosophique,  66:561-93,  December  1908.  70 

An  analysis  and  explanation  of  the  phenomenon  of  "d£ja  vu."  The 
memory  image  is  contemporaneous  with  the  perception.  Every  moment 
of  life  shows  two  faces,  perception  and  memory.  Why  is  the  present  not 
commonly  experienced  as  both  perceived  and  remembered?  In  general, 
the  past  recurs  normally  to  consciousness  only  when  it  can  aid  in  under- 
standing the  present  or  anticipating  the  future;  it  clarifies  action.     What 

12 


however,  could  be  more  useless  for  present  action  than  memory  of  the 
present?  Consciousness  is  intent  upon  the  process  of  living.  False 
recognition  results  from  a  temporary  weakening  of  this  attention  to 
living.  The  relaxation  permits  consciousness  to  swerve  from  its  natural 
direction  and  to  notice  what  it  has  no  interest  in  perceiving. 

Rapport  sur  le  concours  pour  le  prix  Le  Dissex  de  Penanrun,  1 94  >; 
Memoires   de  V Academic  des  sciences  morales  et  politiques, 
26:771-85,  1909.  7i 

Rapport  sur  un  ouvrage  de  M.  Emile  Meyerson:  Identite  et 
realite.  Seances  et  travaux  de  V  Academie  des  sciences  morales 
et  politiques  (Seance  du  23  Janvier  1909),  171:664-6,  May 
1909.  72 

Rapport  sur  un  ouvrage  de  M.  Henri  Delacroix:  Etudes  d'his- 
toire  et  de  psychologie  du  mysticisme.  Seances  et  travaux 
de  V Academie  des  sciences  morales  et  politiques  (Seance  du 
30  janvicr  1909),  171 :  670-671,  May  1909.  73 

Tarde,  Gabriel.  Gabriel  Tarde,  Introduction  et  pages  choisies 
par  ses  fils  .  .  .  preface  de  H.  Bergson.  Paris,  Louis 
Michaud,  1909.  223  p.  (Les  grands  philosophes  francais 
et  etrangers.)  74 

L'inconscient  dans  la  vie  mentale.  Bulletin  de  la  Societe 
frangaise  de  philosophic,  10:17-51,  January  1910.  75 

General  discussion  at  the  meeting  of   the  society,  25  No- 
vember 1909.     M.  Bergson's  remarks,  p.  31-36,  43~46- 

Rapport  sur  un  ouvrage  de  M.  Lionel  Dauriac:  Le  musicien- 
poete  Richard  Wagner:  etude  de  psychologie  musicale. 
Seances  et  travaux  de  V Academie  des  sciences  morales  et 
politiques  (Seance  du  16  avril  1910),  173:803-805,  June 
1910.  76 

Rapport  sur  un  ouvrage  de  M.  Andre  Joussain:  Le  fondement 
psychologique  de  la  morale.  Seances  et  travaux  de  VA  cadem  ie 
des  sciences  morales  et  politiques  (Seance  du  14  mai  19 10), 
173:816-817.  June  1910.  77 

13 


A  propos  d'un  article  de  Mr.  W.  B.  Pitkin  intitule  James  and 
Bergson.  Journal  of  philosophy,  psychology,  and  scientific 
methods,  7:385-88,  July  1910.  78 

Rapport  sur  un  ouvrage  de  M.  Barrett  Wendell:  La  France 
d'aujourd'hui.  Seances  et  travaux  deV Academic des  sciences 
morales  et  politiques  (Seance  du  11  juin  1910),  174:146-148, 
July  1 910.  79 

Rapport  sur  le  concours  pour  les  prix  Charles  Leveque,  a  decerner 
en  1910.  Seances  et  travaux  de  V  Academie  des  sciences 
morales  et  politiques  (Seance  du  22  octobre  19 10),  174: 
496-501,  1910.  80 

Le  pragmatisme,  par  William  James,  traduit  par  E.  Le  Brun,  avec 
une  introduction  par  H.  Bergson.  Paris,  Ernest  Flammarion, 
191 1.  312  p.  (Bibliotheque  de  philosophic  scientifique.) 
Introduction  par  H.  Bergson,  Verite  et  realite,  p.  1-16.     81 

Choix  de  textes.  Notice  par  Rene  Gillouin.  Paris,  Louis 
Michaud,  191 1.     222  p.  82 

Life  and  consciousness.  Hibbert  journal,  10:24-44,  October 
1911-  83 

The  Huxley  Lecture,  delivered  at  the  University  of  Birmingham,  29 
May  191 1,  with  some  additions. 

La  perception  du  changement:  conferences  faites  a  l'universite 
d'Oxford  les  26  et  27  mai  191 1.  Oxford,  The  Clarendon 
Press,  191 1.    37  p.  84 

TRANSLATION 

Vospriiatie  izmienchivosti.     [Trans,  by  V.  A.  Flerov.]     St. 
Petersburg,  191 2*  84a 

L'Intuition  philosophique.  Revue  de  metaphysique  et  de  morale, 
1 9 :  809-2  7 ,  November  1 9 1 1 .  85 

A  paper  read  at  the  Congress  of  Philosophy  at  Bologna  in  191 1.  A 
great  philosopher,  whether  he  live  at  one  time  or  another,  will  say  essen- 
tially the  same  thing.  If  Spinoza  had  lived  before  Descartes  he  would, 
no  doubt,  have  written  other  books,  but  given  Spinoza  we  should  be  sure 
of  Spinozism.  Experience  presents  itself  in  two  aspects,  that  of  repeating 
facts  external  to  one  another  and  that  of  uninterrupted  duration  repelling 

14 


measurement.  The  matter  and  life  that  fill  the  world  are  in  us  too.  It 
pertains  to  philosophy  to  apprehend  the  process  and  becoming  which  is 
the  life  of  things.  Consciousness  turns  within  and  sounds  the  depths  of 
her  own  being. 
Filosofien  och  livet.  Fyra  foredrag.  Till  svenska  av  Algot 
Ruhe.     Stockholm,  191 1.     77  P-*  86 


15 


PART  II 

BOOKS  AND  ARTICLES  ABOUT  BERGSON 

1890 

Belot,  G.     Une  thtorie  tiouvelle  de  la  liberty.      Revue  philoso- 
phigue  \o:  \6o  92,  October  [890.  87 

Ferri,  Luigi.     Bssai  sur  les  donnees  immddiates  de  la  conscu  • 

Rivistd  italiami  di  filosofia,  5:  a  48   49,  March— April  1890.    88 
Herr,  Lucien.     II.  Bergson:    Bssai  sur  les  donnees  imm£diates 

!<■::■■    critique,  n.  s.,  30:517-19,  29   De- 

89 

Reviewed  with  leveral  other  works. 

Lechalas,  G.     Le  aombre  et  le  temps  dans  lews  rapports  avec 

l'<  de  Les  donnees  innnediates.     Annates  de 

philosophic  chrcticnnc,  n.  s.,  23:516   540,  1N90.*  90 

Levy-Bruhl,  L.     LT  imm£diates  de  la  con- 

Lence  [Revu    critique].     Revue  philosophiquc.  29:519-38, 

91 

Stout,  G.  F.     Free  will  and  determinism      Speaker  (London), 
1    520    10  May  1890.*  92 

Whittaker,  T.     E  »ai  sur  les  donnees  immerJiates  de  la  conscience 
new].     Mind,  [5:292  93,  April  i>-  93 

1891 

Pillon,  F.     B  Henri):  1  donnees  immecliates 

Annie  philosophiquc,  iSqo,    1:227-28, 

'<  94 

*  16 


-'-/■ 


iturat,  Louis.     Etudes   sur  Fespace  :      MM 

Lechalas,  Poincare,  Delboeuf,  Bergson   L         beret Eveffin. 

Revue  de  metaphysique  et  de  morale,  4:646-69,  September 

1896.  95 

lillee,  Alfred.     Le  mouv-ement  idealiste  et  la  reaction  contre 

la  science  positive.    P;~      P  4Iix  Alcan.  1896.    lxviii,  351  p. 

Bergson,  p.  :        :  A. 
rdiner,  H.  N.     Memoire  et  reconnaissance.      ?.-"•.."' 

chological  reciera        =  ~  *  -  * ;    September  1896. 
rozzi,  Giuseppe .     Delia  necessita  del  fatto  natnrale  ed  umano. 

Torino.  Ermanno  Loescher    1 '-.'/.— "-"      2  v  5-8 


-  ^ 


y 


&9I 


jxander,  S.     Matiere  et  memoire  [Review].     Mind,  21   --:-- 

October  189-  ;; 

lot,  Gustave.    Un  nouveau  spin : •;.  =. '.: .\rr. :     F 
44:183-99,  August  1897  :■:•: 

Review  of  Matiere  et  memoire. 

Ibos,  Victor.     Matiere  et  memoire      I  ssai  strr  la  relation  dn 
corps  a  lesprit,  par  Henri  Bergson  [Etude  critique],    Rome 

de  metaphysique  et  de  morale,  5:353-89,  May  189"  10 1 

chalas,  G.     Matiere  et  memoirs  i  ~~.-^\  ir.  -cuveau  Livrt  it 

M.  Bergson.     Annates  de  philosophic  ckre:  n 

147-64.  314-54.   [•>: 

argerie,  Amedil  de.     La  philosophie  de  M.  Fotrfllee 
de  philosophie  chre:  -      i:~-i\    625-47    -  "  -~  * 

Hon,  F.     Bergson  Henri 

.i--.nee  philosophique    1 :  ; :     -   190-92,  1897. 

Iszecker,  A.     Rffimoil  :onnaissanee.     [Recension.1    Z«d- 

scto/?   /ttr   psychoiogie    und  physiofogie  der  nnnesorgane, 

13:229-32,  1-    -  105 

17 


102 


I  3  3 


IG4 


Rauh,  F.  La  conscience  du  devenir.  Revue  de  metaphysique 
et  de  morale,  5:659-81,  6:38-60,  November  1897,  January 
1898.  106 

1898 

Jacob,  B.  La  philosophic  d'hier  et  celle  d'aujourd'hui.  Revue 
de  metaphysique  et  de  morale,  6: 170-201,  March  1898.    106a 

Ziehen,  Th.  H.  Bergson:  Matiere  et  memoire  [Recension]. 
Zeitschrift  fur  philosophie  und  philosophische  kritik,  n.  s., 
113:295-99,  December  1898.  107 

1899 

Masci,  Filippo.  L'idealismo  indeterminista.  Naples  A  ccademia 
di  scienze  morali  et  politiche.     Atti,  30:35-184,  1899.       108 

1900 

Brunschvicg,  Leon.  L'idealisme  contemporain.  Bibliothe'que 
du  congres  international:  1.  Philosophie  generate  et  meta- 
physique, 1900.  109 
Bergson,  p.  39~57- 

Dauriac,  Lionel.  Henri  Bergson.  Le  rire.  [Analyse.]  Revue 
philosophique,  50:665-70,  December  1900.  no 

Le  Roy,  Edouard.  Science  et  philosophie.  Revue  de  metaphy- 
sique et  de  morale,  8:37-72,  January  1900.  in 

Morselli,  E.  Un  nuovo  idealismo  (H.  Bergson).  Udine,  Foso- 
lini,  1900.*  112 

Paulhan,  Fr.  Contemporary  philosophy  in  France.  Philo- 
sophical review,  9:42-69,  January  1900.  113 

Petrone,Igino.  I  limiti  del  determinismo  scientifico.  Modena, 
1900;    Roma,  1903.*  114 

1 901 

C.,  J.     College  de   France,   Cours  de  M.  Bergson  sur 

l'id^e  de  cause.    Revue  de  philosophie,  1 :  358-388,  April  1901 . 

115 
1*8 


Grosse,  Ernst.  Henri  Bcrgson:  Le  rire.  Deutsche  litteratur- 
zeitung,  22: 13-14,  5  January  1901.  116 

Heymans.  Lc  rire.  Essai  sur  la  signification  du  comique 
[Recension].  Zeitschrift  fur  psychologie  und  physiologic 
der  sinnesorgane,  25:155-156,  1901.  117 

Landormy,  P.  Remarques  sur  la  philosophic  nouvellc  et  sur 
ses  rapports  avec  l'intellectualisme.  Revue  de  metaphysique 
et  de  morale,  9:478-86,  July  1901.  Il8 

Parodi,  D.  Le  rire,  par  H.  Bergson.  Revue  de  metaphysique 
et  de  morale,  9:224-36,  March  1901.  119 

Pillon,  F.  Bergson,  Henri:  Le  rire  [Revue  critique].  Annee 
philosophique,  1900,  11:135-38,  1901-  I20 

Sarlo,  F.  de.  Le  correnti  filosofiche  de  secola  XIX.  Flegrea, 
3:531-54,  20  September  1901.*  I21 

Tufts,  J.  H.  Humor:  Le  rire,  essai  sur  la  signification  du  co- 
mique. H.  Bergson  [Review].  Psychological  review,  8 :  98-99, 
January  1901.  I22 

1902 

Binet,  A.  H.  Bergson:  Note  sur  la  conscience  de  1' effort  intel- 
lectuel.  4.  Congres  international  de  psychologie,  Paris, 
1901  [Analyse].  Annee  psychologique,  1901,  8:471-78, 
1902.  I23 

Couchoud,  Paul  Louis.  La  metaphysique  nouvelle,  Matiere  et 
memoire  de  M.  Bergson  [Etude  critique].  Revue  de  meta- 
physique et  de  morale,  10:  225-43,  March  1902.  124 

Giessler.  Le  reve.  [Recension.]  Zeitschrift  filr  psychologie  und 
physiologie  der  sinnesorgane,  29:231,  1902.  125 

Leclere,  Albert.  Le  mouvement  catholique  kantien  en  France. 
Kant  studien,  hrsg.  von  Hans  Vaihinger  und  Max  Scheler, 
7:300-63,  1902.  I2° 

Bergson,  p.  314-62. 
MacDonald,    M.    S.      L'effort    intellectuel,    par    H.    Bergson 
[Review].     Philosophical  review,  11 :  416-17,  July  1902.    127 

19 


Moisant,  Xavier.  La  notion  de  multiplicity  dans  la  philosophic 
de  M.  Bergson.    Revue  de  philosophie,  2:447-65,  June  1902. 

128 

Steeg,  T.  Henri  Bergson:  Notice  biographique  avec  portrait. 
Revue  universelle,  12:15-16,  January  1902.  129 

1903 

Cantecor,  G.  La  philosophic  nouvelle  et  la  vie  de  l'esprit. 
Revue  philosophique,  55:252-77,  March  1903.  130 

Giessler.  L'effort  intellectuel  [Recension].  Zeitschrift  fur 
psychologie  und  physiologie  der  sinnesorgane,  32:128-29,  1903. 

131 

Gurewitsch,   A.     Die  franzosische  metaphysik  der  gegenwart 

(H.  Bergson)  aus  dem  nachlass  von  A.  Gurewitsch.     Archiv 

fur  systematische  philosophie,  n.  s.  9:463-90,  25  November 

1903-  x32 

Ziehen,  Henri  Bergson:  Le  rire  [Recension].  Zeitschrift  filr 
philosophie  und  philosophische  kritik,  n.  s.,  123:215-16,1903. 

133 
1904 

Blum,  Eugene.  Le  He  Congres  international  de  philosophie, 
Geneve,  4-8  septembre  1904.  Revue  philosophique,  58: 
505-19,  November  1904.  134 

Boucaud,  Charles.  L'histoire  de  droit  et  la  philosophie  de  M. 
Bergson.     Revue  de  philosophie,  4:299-306,  1  March  1904. 

135 

Coignet,  C.     Kant  et  Bergson.     Revue  chretienne,  July  1904.*  136 

Constant,  Leonard.  Cours  de  M.  Bergson,  1902-03,  sur  l'his- 
toire de  l'idee  de  temps.  Revue  de  philosophie,  4:  105-111, 
January  1904.  137 

Summary  of  the  lectures. 

Prezzolini,  G.  Del  linguaggio  come  causa  di  errore  (H.  Bergson) . 
Firenze,  Spinelli,  1904.*        .  138 

20 


Rauh,  F.     Sur  la  position  du  probleme  du  1  Revue 

mStaphysique  et  de  morale,  12:977-1006,  November  I9<>4- 

i39 

1905 

Brunschvicg,Leon.    L'idealisme contemporain.    Paris,  1905.*  140 

Ceresole,  P.  Le  parallelisme  psycho-physiologique  et  1' argu- 
ment dc  M.  Bergson.  Archives  de  psychologies  5:112-20, 
October  1905.  I4I 

Dwelshauvers,  Georges.  Raison  et  intuition,  Etude  sur  la  philo- 
sophic de  M.  Bergson.  La  Belgique  artistique  et  litter  aire, 
November-December  1905,  April  1906.*  i42 

Introduction  a  la  metaphysique,  par  Henri  Bergson.  Jcnnesse 
laique,  1905,  no.  37,  p.  223-232,  1905-*  J43 

Levi,  A.  L'indeterminismo  nella  filosofia  francese  contemporanea : 
La  filosofia  della  contingenza.  Firenze,  Bernardo  Seeber, 
1905.     x,  300  p.  T44 

Henri  Bergson,  p.  81-125. 

Moisant,  Xavier.  Dieu  dans  la  philosophic  de  M.  Bergson. 
Revue  de  philosophic,  6:  495-518,  May  1905.  145 

Rageot,  Gaston.  Correspondance  avec  M.  Bergson  sur  sa  re- 
lation a  M.  W.  James.  Revue  philo soph i que,  60:  229-231, 
July  1905.  I46 

Rageot,  Gaston.  Le  congres  international  de  psychologic 
Revue  philosophique,  60:67-87,  July  1905.  147 

Varisco,  B.  La  filosofia  della  contingenza.  Rivista  filosofica, 
8:  3-37,  January-February  1905.  x48 

1906 

Blum,  Jean.  La  philosophic  de  M.  Bergson  et  la  poesie  sym- 
boliste.     Mercurede  France,  63:201-07,  15  September  1906. 

149 

Lalande,  Andre.  Philosophy  in  France  (1905)-  Philosophical 
review,  15:241-66,  May  1906.  150 

21 


Luquet,  G.  H.  Idees  generates  de  psychologic  Paris,  Felix 
Alcan,  1906.     vii,  295  p.  151 

Dedicated  to  L.  LeVy-Bruhl  and  H.  Bergson,  and  influenced  largely  by 
the  ideas  of  Bergson. 

Lux,  Jacques.  Nos  philosophes:  M.  Bergson.  Revue  politique 
et  litteraire,  Revue  bleue,  5th  ser.,  6:  703-04,  1  December 
1906.  152 

Sauvage,  George  M.  The  new  philosophy  in  France.  Catholic 
university  bulletin,  12:  147-59,  April  1906.  153 

1907 

Balthaser,  Nicholas.  Le  probleme  de  Dieu  d'apres  la  philosophie 
nouvelle.  Revue  neo-scolastique,  14:449-89,  15:90-124,  No- 
vember 1907,  February  1908.  154 

Berthelot,  Rene.  Discussion:  Sur  la  necessite,  la  finalite  et  la 
liberte  chez  Hegel.  Bulletin  de  la  Societe  frangaise  de  philo- 
sophie (Seance  du  Janvier  1907),  7:119-40,  April  1907.    155 

La  psychologie  de  M.  Bergson,  p.  136-38. 

Reprinted  with  some  changes  in  his  Evolutionisme  et  platonisme. 

Besse,  Clement.  Lettre  de  France.  Pour  rintellectualisme. 
Revue  neo-scolastique,  14:  281-303,  August  1907.  156 

Boyd,  W.  L'evolution  creatrice.  Review  of  theology  and 
philosophy,  3:249-51,  October  1907.  157 

Calderon,  F.  Garcia.  Dos  filosofos  franceses,  Bergson  y  Bou- 
troux.     El  comer cio  (Lima),  5  May  1907.  158 

Duprat,  G.  L.  La  spatialite"  des  faits  psychiques.  Revue  philo- 
sophique,  63:  492-501,  May  1907.  159 

Dwelshauvers,  Georges.  M.  Bergson  et  la  methode  intuitive. 
Revue  du  mois,  4:336-50,  September  1907.  160 

Dwelshauvers,  Georges.  M.  Bergson  et  la  methode  intuitive. 
Samedi,  no.  44,  1907.*  .  161 

22 


Fontana,  Paul.  Cours  de  M.  Bergson  au  College  de  France. 
Theories  de  la  volonte\  Revue  de  philosophie,  11:70-91, 
407-27,  July,  October  1907.  l62 

Hollard,  A.  devolution  creatrice.  Foi  et  vie,  p.  545~50>  l6 
September  1907.*  ^3 

Janssens,  Edgar.  Georges  Dwelshau vers:  Raison  et  intuition. 
Etude  sur  la  philosophie  de  M.  Henri  Bergson  [Revue 
critique].    Revue neo-scolastique,  14: 140-142,  February  1907. 

164 

Le  Dantec,  Felix.  La  biologie  de  M.  Bergson.  Revue  du  mois, 
4:230-41,  August  1907.  T"5 

Noel,  L.  Bulletin  d'epistemologie.  Le  pragmatisme.  Revue 
neo-scolastique,  14:220-243,  May  1907.  166 

Prins,  Adolphe.  L'evolution  et  la  conception  materialiste  de 
l'univers.  Revue  de  V University  de  Bruxelles,  13:29-67, 
October  1907.  x^7 

Rageot,  Gaston.  Revue  critique :  L'evolution  creatrice.  Revue 
philosophique,  64:  73-85,  July  1907.  168 

Tonquedec,  Joseph  de.  La  notion  de  verite  dans  la  philosophie 
nouvelle.  Etudes  par  des  peres  de  la  compagnie  de  Jesus, 
110:721-48,  112:68-82,335-61,20  March,  5  July,  5  August 
1907.  l6° 

Weber,  Louis.  L'evolution  creatrice  [Etude  critique] .  Revue  de 
metaphysique  et  de  morale,  15:620-70,  September  1907.    170 

1908 

Aimel,  Georges.  Individualisme  et  philosophie  bergsonienne. 
Revue  de  philosophie,  12:582-93,  June  1908.  171 

Antoniade,  C.  Filosofia  lui  Henri  Bergson.  Studii  filosofice 
(Bucarest),  2: 161-92,  259-78,  1908.*  172 

23 


NJ 


Ardigo,  Roberto.  Una  pretesa  pregiudiziale  contro  il  positivismo. 
Rivista  di  filosofia  e  scienze  affini,  Jan -Feb.,  Mar.-April, 
1908.  173 

Reprinted  in  his  collected  works,  1908,  vol.  10. 

Batault,  Georges.  La  philosophic  de  M.  Bergson.  Mercure  de 
France,  72: 193-211,  16  March  1908.  174 

Berthelot,  Rene.  Evolutionisme  et  platonisme,  melanges  d'his- 
toire  de  la  philosophic  et  d'histoire  des  sciences.  Paris, 
Felix  Alcan,  1908.     iv,  326  p.  175 

A  propos  de  l'idee  de  la  vie  chez  Guyau,  chez  Nietzsche  et  chez  Bergson, 
P-  131-38. 

Bode,  B.  H.  L'evolution  creatrice  [Review].  Philosophical  re- 
view, 17:84-89,  January  1908.  176 

Chaumeix,  Jean  Henri  Andre.  La  philosophic  de  Bergson. 
Journal  des  debats,  1908:1027-32,  24  May  1908.  177 

Reprinted  in  Pragmatisme  et  modernisme,  1909. 

Chide,  Alphonse.  Le  mobilisme  moderne.  Paris,  Felix  Alcan, 
1908.*  178 

Chide,  Alphonse.  Pragmatisme  etintellectualisme.  Revue  philo- 
sophise, 65:367-88,  April  1908.  179 

Crespi,   A.     La   metafisica  di  H.  Bergson.     Coenobium,  2:  no. 

5:46-51,  July- August  1908.  180 

Cristiani,   Leon.     Le   probleme   de    Dieu    et   le    pragmatisme. 

Paris,  Bloud  et  cie.,1908.  181 

Decoster,  P.     La  philosophie  de  M.  Bergson.     Pages  amies,  no. 

6,  1908.*  182 

Driesch,  Hans.     H.  Bergson,  der  biologische  philosoph.     Zeit- 

schrift  filr  den  Ausbau  der  entwickelungslehre,  2:  hft.   1-2, 

1908.  183 

Duprat,  E.     Estudios   de  filosofia   contemporanea :    la  filosofia 

de  H.  Bergson.     Caltura  espanola  (Madrid),  pt.  1-2:   185- 

202,  567-84,  1908.*  184 

24 


Dwelshauvers,  Georges.     Dc  l'intuition  dans  Tact*   de  l'esprit. 

Revue   de     metaphysiqiie   et  de  morale,    16:55-65,    January 

190S.  l85 

Gebert,  K.     Philosophic  d.  innerwelt,  deutschc  Uebertragg.  d. 

philosophic  Bergsons.     Das  20.  Jahrhundert,  Augsburg,  no. 

48,  1908.*  l86 

Keyserling,  H.  von.     Bergson.     Allgemeine  zeitung  (Miinchen), 

28  November  1908.*  l87 

Kodis,  J.     Philosophic  de  Bergson.     Przeglad  filosoficzny,  1908.* 

188 

Lalande,  Andre.  Philosophy  in  France  (1907):  I.  Philosophy 
in  the  universities.  Philosophical  review,  17:291-306, 
May   1908.  l89 

Le  Dantec,  Felix.  Science  et  conscience.  Paris,  Flammarion, 
1908.     328  p.  I9° 

Legendre,  M.  Bergson  et  son  Evolution  crea trice.  Bulletin 
de  la  semaine,  6  May  1908.*  191 

Lenoble.  L' evolution  creatrice.  Revue  du  clerge  francais, 
January  1908.*  192 

Loveday,  T.  Involution  creatrice,  par  Henri  Bergson  [Re- 
view].    Mind,  n.  s.,  17:402-08,  July  1908.  193 

Mitchell,  A.  L'evolution  creatrice  [Review].  Journal  of  phi- 
losophy, psychology  and  scientific  methods,  5:603-12,  22 
October  1908.  J94 

Mondain,  G.  Remarqucs  sur  la  theorie  materialiste.  Foi  et  vie, 
P  369-73.  15  June  1908.*  195 

Palmer,  William  Scott.  Presence  and  omnipresence.  A  Chris- 
tian study  aided  by  the  philosophy  of  Monsieur  Bergson. 
Contemporary  review,  93:734-42,  June  1908.  196 

Parodi,  D.  Les  tendances  de  la  philosophic  contemporainc  en 
France.     Petit  messager  beige,  no.  421,  pp.  S0-^1'  I9°8-*    *97 

Pegnes,  Thomas  M.  L'evolution  creatrice.  Revue  thorn iste, 
16:137-63,  May-June  1908.  198 

25 


Piat,  Clodius.  Insuffisance  des  philosophies  de  l'intuition.  Paris, 
Plonnourrit  et  cie.,  1908.     319  p.  199 

Pillon,  F.  Bergson,  Henri.  L'evolution  creatrice  [Revue 
critique].     Annee  philosophique,  1907,  18: 182-84,  1908.    200 

Rageot,  Gaston.  Les  savants  et  la  philosophie.  Paris.  Felix 
Alcan,  1908.  179  p.  (Bibliotheque  de  philosophie  contem- 
poraine.)  201 

Ross,  G.  R.  T.  A  new  theory  of  laughter.  (Review  of  Le  rire.) 
Nation  {London),  4:348-49,  28  November  1908.  202 

Sauvage,  George  M.  The  new  philosophy  in  France.  II.  The 
principles  of  psychology.  Catholic  university  bulletin,  14: 
268-86,  March  1908.  203 

Schoen,  H.  Bergson,  Henri:  L'evolution  creatrice  [Recension]. 
Zeitschrift fur  philosophie  und  padagogik,  15:39-41, 1908.  204 

Silberstein.     L'evolution  creatrice.     Przeglad  filosoficzny,  1908. 

205 

Smith,  Norman.  Subjectivism  and  realism  in  modern  philoso- 
phy.    Philosophical  review,  17: 138-48,  March  1908.        206 

Sorel,  Georges.  L'evolution  creatrice.  Le  mouvement  social- 
iste,  22:257-82,  478-91;  23:34-52,  184-94,  276-94;  15 
October,  15  December  1907;  15  January,  15  March,  15 
April  1908.  207 

Tonquedec,  Joseph  de.  Comment  interpreter  l'ordre  du  monde, 
a  propos  du  dernier  ouvrage  de  M.  Bergson.  Etudes  par  des 
plres  de  la  compagnie  de  Jesus,  5  March  1908.  208 

Tonquedec,  Joseph  de.  Comment  interpreter  l'ordre  du  monde, 
a  propos  du  dernier  ouvrage  de  M.  Bergson.  Paris,  Beau- 
chesne,  1908.*  209 

Tonquedec,  J.  de.  La  notion  de  la  verite  dans  la  philosophie 
nouvelle.     Paris,   1908.*  210 

Trouche,  H.  L'evolution  creatrice  [Revue  critique].  Revue 
de  philosophie,  13:520-34,  November  1908.  211 

26* 


Tyrrell,  G.  devolution  creatrice  [Review].  Hibbert  journal, 
6:435-42,  January  1908.  2I2 

Varisco,  B.  La  creazione.  Rivista  filosofica,  1 1 :  149-80,  March- 
April  1908.  2I3 

Villassere,  H.  Involution  creatrice.  Bulletin  critique,  p.  392- 
411,  September  1908.*  2I4 

Wolf,  A.  Natural  realism  and  present  tendencies  in  philosophy. 
Aristotelian  society.     Proceedings,  9:141-82,  1908-1909.  215 

1909 

Baylac,  Jacques.     La  philosophie  de  M.  Bergson.     Bulletin  de 

litterature  ecclesiastique  publie  par  VInstitut   Catholique  de 

Toulouse,  p.  329-41,  October  1909.*  2l6 

Bergson's  new  idea.     Current  literature,  47:650-51,  December 

1909.  2I7 

Boer,  T.  J.  de.     De  filosofie  van  Henri  Bergson.      Beweging,  3: 

225-44,  1909-  2l8 

Bougie,    C.     Syndicalistes    et    Bergsoniens.     Revue    du     mois, 

7:403-16,  April  1909.  2I9 

Braun,  O.     Materie  und  gedachtnis  [Recension].     Archiv  fur  die 

gesamte  psychologie  (Literaturbericht) ,  15:13-151  I9°9-      22° 
Carr,  H.  Wildon.     Bergson's  theory  of  knowledge.      A ristotelia n 

society.     Proceedings,  n.  s.,  9:  41-60,  1909.  221 

Chaumeix,  Jean  Henri  Andre.     Le  philosophie  de  M.  Bergson. 

(In  Bordeau,  J.  A.  B.,  Pragmatisme  et  modernisme,  p.  221- 

236,  Paris,  1909.)*  222 

Reprinted  from  Journal  des  Debats,  May  24,   1908.     A  review  of  Henri 

Bergson's  l'Evolution  creatrice. 
Chide,    Alphonse.     Autour   du    probleme    de   la    connaissance. 

Revue    philosophique,  68:  581-604,  December  1909.         223 
Farges,  Albert.     L'erreur  fondamentale  de  la  philosophie  nou- 

velle.     Revue   thomiste,    17:182-97.    299-312,    March-June 
1909.*  224 

27 


y 


*t 


Farges,  Albert.  Le  probleme  de  la  contingence  d'apres  M. 
Bergson.     Revue  pratique  d'apologetique,  15  April  1909.*  225 

Farges,  Albert.  La  theorie  fondamentale  de  l'acte,  avec  la 
critique  de  la  philosophie  nouvelle  de  M.  Bergson.  Paris, 
Berche  et  Tralin,  1909.*  226 

Ferrar,  W.  J.  L 'evolution  creatrice.  Commonwealth,  p.  364- 
67,  December  1909.*  227 

Garringou-Lagrange,  Fr.  Le  sens  commun,  la  philosophie  de 
l'etre  et  les  formules  dogmatiques.  Paris,  Beauchesne, 
1909.*  22& 

Goldstein,  J.  Henri  Bergson  und  der  Zeitlosigkeitsidealismus. 
Liter aturblatt  der  Frankfurter  zeitung,  2  May  1909.*         229 

Grivet,  Jules.  Henri  Bergson.  Esquisse  philosophique.  Etudes 
par  des  peres  de  la  Compagnie  de  Jesus,  121 :  31-50,  454-78, 
124: 153-84,  5-20  November  1909,  20  July  1910.  230 

Hulme,  T.  E.  The  new  philosophy.  New  age,  n.  s.,  5:I98- 
99,  1  July  1909.  231 

Hulme,  T.  E.  Searchers  after  reality.  I:  Bax.  New  age,  n.  s., 
5 :  265-66,  29  July  1909.  232 

James,  William.  Philosophy  of  Bergson.  Hibbert  journal, 
7:  562-77,   April   1909.  233 

Reprinted  in  his  Pluralistic  universe,  N.  Y.,  1909,  p.  223-73. 

James,  William.  A  pluralistic  universe.  New  York,  Longmans, 
Green  &  co.,  1909.     vi,  405  p.  234 

The  philosophy  of  Bergson  and  his  critique  of  intellectualism,  p.  223- 
73.     Reprinted  from  Hibbert  Journal,  7:  562-77,  April  1909. 

Kodis,   J.      Die   schopferische   evolution  von    Bergson   [poln. 

sprache].     Przeglad  filosofizny,  vol.  11,  1909 .*  235 

Leclere,  Albert.      Pragmatismc,    modernisme,   protestantisme. 

Paris,  Bloud  et  cie.,  1909.     296  p.  236 

Lovejoy,  A.  O.      The  metaphysician  of  the  life  force.      Nation 

(N.  Y.),  89:298-301,  30  September  1909.  237 

Review  of  Evolution  creatrice. 

28' 


Momigliano,  Attilio.  L'origine  del  comico.  La  ciiitura  filosofica, 
3:406-433,    September-October  1909.  238 

Palmer,  William  Scott.  Life  and  the  brain.  Contemporary 
review,  96  :  474-84,  October  1909.  239 

[Palmer,  William  Scott.]  Thought  and  instinct.  Nation  (Lon- 
don), 5  :  341-342,  5  June  1909.  240 

Prezzolini,  Giuseppe.  La  teoria  sindacalista.  Napoli,  Frances- 
co Perella,  1909.  338  p.  241 
La  filosofia  di  Enrico  Bergson,  chapter  III,  p.  281-335. 

Raymond,  P.  La  philosophic  de  l'intuition  et  la  philosophie 
du  concept.     Etudes  franciscaines,  21:669-87,  June  1909. 

242 

Ross,  G.  T.  The  philosophy  of  vitalism.  Nation  (London),  4: 
902-03,  13  March  1909.  243 

Seilliere,  E.  L'Allemagne  et  la  philosophie  bergsonienne. 
V opinion,  3  July  1909.*  244 

Seliber,  G.  Der  pragmatismus  und  seine  gegner  auf  dem  III. 
internationalen  kongress  fur  philosophie.  Archiv  fur  sys- 
tematise philosophie,  15:287-98,   1909.  245 

Steenbergen,  Albert.  Henri  Bergsons  intuitive  philosophie. 
Rudolstadt,  Manicke  und  Jahn,  1909.     46  p.  246 

Jena,  Phil.  Diss.,  21  September  1909. 

Steenbergen,  Albert.  Henri  Bergsons  intuitive  philosophie. 
Jena,  E.  Diederichs,  1909.     109  p.  247 

Bibliographic  p.  2-5. 

I9IO 

Antioniade,  C.  Filosofia  lui  Henri  Bergson.  Studii  filosofice 
(Bucarest),  5:24-59,  1 13-169,  1910.*  248 

Becher,  Erich.  Bergson,  H:  Materie  und  gedachtnis.  Liter- 
arisches  centralblatt  fur  Deutschland,  61.  Jahrgang  :  9i7~l8, 
9  July  1910.  249 

29 


4 


Benrubi,  Isaak.  Albert  Steenbergen :  Henri  Bergson's  intuitive 
philosophie  [Revue  critique].  Revue  philosophique,  69  : 
204-206,  February  1910.  250 

Benrubi,  Isaak.  Henri  Bergson.  Die  zukunft,  71  :  318-22, 
4  June  1910.  251 

Bornhausen,  K.  Die  philosophie  Henri  Bergsons  und  ihre  be- 
deutung  fur  den  religionsbegriff.  Zeitschrift  filr  theologie 
und  kirche,  20  :  39-77,  1910.*  252 

Bosanquet,  Bernard.  Prediction  of  human  conduct :  a  study  in 
Bergson.  International  journal  of  ethics,  21  :  1-15,  October 
1910.  253 

An  address  delivered  at  University  College,  Cardiff;  an  attempt  to  make 
clear  to  a  general  audience  Bergson's  position  on  certain  questions. 

Carr,  H.  Wildon.  Bergson  theory  of  instinct.  Aristotelian 
society.     Proceedings,  n.  s.,  10  :  93-114,  1910.  254 

Carr,  H.  Wildon.  The  philosophy  of  Henri  Bergson.  Hibbert 
journal,  8  :  873-83,  July  1910.  255 

Chaumeix,  Andre.  Les  critiques  du  rationalisme  a  propos  des 
idees  de  M.  Bergson  et  de  M.  William  James.  Revue 
hebdomadaire,  p.  1-33,  1  January  1910.  256 

Corbiere,  Charles.  Le  dieu  de  M.  Bergson.  Revue  de  theologie 
et  des  questions  religieuses,  p.  176-87,  March  1910.*         257 

Dienes,  V.  and  Dienes,  P.  Bemerkungen  zur  metaphysik  Berg- 
sons [Ungar.  sprache].     Husz.  szds.,  1910.*  258 

Dolson,  Grace  Neal.  The  philosophy  of  Henri  Bergson.  Philo- 
sophical review,  19  :  579-96,  20  :  46-58,  November  1910- 
January  191 1.  259 

Eschbach,  V.  Henri  Bergson.  Kolnische  volkszeitung,  20  Jan- 
uary 1910.*  260 

Florence,  Jean.  La  philosophie  de  M.  Bergson,  jug£e  par  M. 
Lasserre.     La  phalange,  p.  218-69, 20  September  1910.*    261 

30- 


Fritzsche,  Richard.  Bergson,  Henri:  Materie  und  gedachtnis, 
Einfuhrung  in  die  metaphysik :  Steenbergen,  Henri  Bergsons 
intuitive  philosophie  [Recensionen].  Vierteljahrschrift 
fur  ivissenschaftliche  philosophie  und  soziologie,  34  :  353-57, 
September  1910.  262 

Gaul  tier,  Jules  de.  Le  realisme  du  continu.  Revue  philoso- 
phy que,  69:39-64,  January  1910.  263 

Gillouin,  Rene.  Henri  Bergson.  Choix  de  textes  avec  etude 
du  systeme  philosophique  par  Rene  Gillouin.  Paris, 
Louis  Michaud,  19 10.     222  p.,  portraits.  264 

Contents : 

1.  M.  Henri  Bergson,  sa  philosophie,  p.  7-36. 

2.  Extraits  des  ceuvres  de  M.  Henri  Bergson,  p.  39-220. 

Goldstein,  Julius.  Henri  Bergson  und  die  sozialwissenschaft. 
Archiv  fiir  sozialwissenschaft  und  sozialpolitik,  31  :  1-22, 
1910.  265 

H.  Bergson.     Coenobium,  4: 141,  1910.*  266 

Jacoby,  Giinther.  Henri  Bergson:  Einfuhrung  in  die  metaphy- 
sik; Albert  Steenbergen,  Henri  Bergsons  intuitive  phi- 
losophie [Recensionen].  Archiv  fiir  die  gesamte  psychologie 
(Literaturbericht),    18  :  19-20,    1910.  267 

James,  William.  Bradley  or  Bergson?  Journal  of  philosophy, 
psychology,  and  scientific  methods,  7  :  29-33,  20  January 
1910.  268 

James,  William.  A  great  French  philosopher  at  Harvard. 
Nation  (N.  Y.),  90:312-314,  31  March  1910.  269 

Jeanniere,  Rene.  La  theorie  des  concepts  chez  M.  Bergson  et 
M.  James.  Revue  de  philosophie,  17  :  578-98,  December 
1910.  270 

Joel,  K.  Neues  denken.  Neue  rundschau,  7:549-58,  April 
1910.*  271 

Joussain,  A.  Romantisme  et  religion.  Paris,  Felix  Alcan, 
1910.*  272 

3i 


Kallen,  H.  M.  James,  Bergson,  and  Mr.  Pitkin.  Journal  of 
philosophy,  psychology,  and  scientific  methods,  7:353-57,  23 
June  1 9 10.  273 

Kroner,  Richard.     Henri  Bergson.     Logos,  1  :  125-150,  1910. 

274 

Lanczi,   E.     Bemerkungen   zur  metaphysik   Bergsons    [Ungar. 

sprache].     6  p.     Husz.  Szdz.,     1910.*  275 

Lasson,  Adolf.     Henri  Bergson.     Deutsche  liter  atur-zeitung,  31  : 

1364-66,  28  May  1910.  276 

Report  of  an  address  on  Bergson. 

Le  Dantec,  Felix.  Reflexions  d'un  philistin  sur  la  metaphysique. 
La  grande  revue,  62: 1-16,  10  July  1910.  276a 

Leighton,  J.  A.  On  continuity  and  discreteness.  Journal  of 
philosophy,  psychology,  and  scientific  methods,  7:231-38,  28 
April  1910.  277 

Muller,  A.  Bergson:  Materie  und  gedachtnis  [Recension]. 
Allgemeine  liter aturblatt,  p.  298,  1910.  278 

Muller-Freienfels,  Richard.  Materie  und  gedachtnis  [Re- 
cension]. Zeitschrift  filr  psychologie  und  physiologie  der 
sinnesorgane,  56  :  126-29,  May  1910.  279 

Pitkin,  Walter  B.  James  and  Bergson;  or,  Who  is  against 
intellect?  Journal  of  philosophy,  psychology,  and  scientific 
methods,  7  :  225-31,  28  April  1910.  280 

Pradines,  Maurice.  Principes  de  toute  philosophic  de  Taction. 
Paris,  1910.*  281 

Prager,  Hans.  Henri  Bergsons  metaphysische  grundanschauung. 
Archiv  filr  systematische  philosophic  n.  s.,  16  :  310-20,  1910. 

282 
Resume  of  Introduction  &  la  metaphysique. 

Prezzolini,  Giuseppe.  H.  Bergson.  Voce,  p.  239-40,  6  January 
1910.*  283 

Professor  Bergson  on  freewill  [Review  of  Time  and  free  will]. 
Spectator,  105  :  465-66,  24  September  1910.  284 

32  * 


Royce,  Josiah.  The  reality  of  the  temporal.  International 
journal  of  ethics,  20:257-71,  April  1910.  285 

Shepherd,  Queen  L.  Le  souvenir  du  present  et  la  fausse  recon- 
naissance [Review].  Psychological  bulletin,  7  1307,  15 
September  1910.  286 

Sobieski,  Michal.  H.  Bergson.  Kurier  warszawski,  20  Jan- 
uary 1910.*  287 

Time  and  free  will :  an  essay  upon  the  immediate  data  of  con- 
sciousness. By  Henri  Bergson.  Authorized  translation 
by  F.  L.  Pogson  [Review].  Athenceum,  iqio,  2  :  483-84, 
22  October  1910.  288 

Time  and  free  will:  an  essay  on  the  immediate  data  of  con- 
sciousness. By  Henri  Bergson.  Authorized  translation  by 
F.  L.  Pogson  [Review].  Nation  (N.  Y.),  91  1499-500, 
24  November  19 10.  289 

Time  and  free  will.  By  Henri  Bergson.  Translation  by  F.  L. 
Pogson  [Review].  Saturday  review,  110:430,  1  October 
1910.  290 

Visan,  Tancrede  de.  La  philosophic  de  M.  Bergson  et  le  lyrisme 
contemporain.     Vers  et  prose,  21 :  125-40,  April- June  19 10. 

291 

1911 

Babynin,  B.  La  philosophic  de  Bergson  (Deux  articles).  Vop- 
rossi  filossofii  i  psychologuii,  January-December  191 1.*    292 

Baldwin,  James  Mark.  Intuition.  American  year  book,  191 1, 
P-  673-74-  293 

Balfour,  Arthur  J.  Creative  evolution  and  philosophic  doubt. 
Hibbert  journal,  10:1-23,  October  191 1;  reprinted  in 
Living  age,  271  :  515-27,  2  December  1911.  294 

Balsillie,  David.  Professor  Bergson  on  time  and  free  will. 
Mind,  n.  s.,  20  :  357-78,  July  191 1.  295 

33 


Bergson  in  English.     Nation  (N.  Y.),  92  :  648-49,  29  June  191 1. 

296 

Review  of  Matter  and  memory,  translated  by  N.  M.  Paul  and  W.  S. 
Palmer;  and  Creative  evolution,  translated  by  Arthur  Mitchell. 

Bergson's  Creative  evolution  [Review],  Saturday  review, 
in  :  685-86,  3  June  191 1.  297 

Bergson's  wonder-working  philosophy.  Current  literature,  50  : 
518-20,  May  191 1.     Portrait.  298 

Reviews  of  Creative  evolution,  translated  by  Arthur  Mitchell;  Matter  and 
memory,  translated  by  N.  M.  Paul  and  W.  S.  Palmer;  and  Time  and 
free  will,  translated  by  F.  L.  Pogson. 

Bjorkman,  Edwin.  Bergson,  the  philosopher  of  actuality. 
Forum,  46  1268-76,  September  191 1.  299 

Bjorkman,  Edwin.  Henri  Bergson:  Philosopher  or  prophet? 
Review  of  reviews,  44  :  250-52,  August  191 1.     Portrait.    300 

Bjorkman,  Edwin.  Is  there  anything  new?  Forum,  46  :  n-21, 
July  191 1.  301 

Bosanquet,  Bernard.  On  a  defect  in  the  customary  logical 
formulation  of  inductive  reasoning.  Aristotelian  society. 
Proceedings,  n.  s.,  11  129-40,  1910-11.  302 

Carr,  H.  Wildon.  The  philosophy  of  Bergson,  by  A.  D.  Lindsay 
[Review].     Mind,  n.  s.,  20  :  560-66,  October  191 1.  303 

Carr,  H.  Wildon.  The  theory  of  psycho-physical  parallelism  as 
a  working  hypothesis  in  psychology.  Aristotelian  society. 
Proceedings,   11  :  129-43,   1910-11.  304 

Cockerell,  J.  D.  A.  The  new  voice  of  philosophy.  Dial,  51  : 
253-55,  1  October  191 1.  305 

Review  of  Creative  evolution. 

Coignet,  C.  De  Kant  a  Bergson.  Reconciliation  de  la  religion 
et  de  la  science  dans  un  spiritualisme  nouveau.  Paris, 
Felix  Alcan,  1911.     155  p.  306 

La  philosophie  de  Bergson,  p.  83-155. 

34 


Creative  evolution.  By  Henri  Bergson.  Authorized  translation 
by  Arthur  Mitchell  [Review].  Athena>um,  iqii,  i  1411- 
12,  15  April  191 1.  307 

Creative  evolution.  By  Henri  Bergson.  Authorized  translation 
by  Arthur  Mitchell  [Review],  Bookman  (N.  Y.),  34  :  206, 
October  191 1.  3°8 

David,  J.  Wf.  O  intuicyi  w  filozofii  Bergsona.  Krytyka,  p. 
92-101,  166-73,  September-October  191 1.  308a 

David,  J.  Wi.  O  intuicyi  w  filozofii  Bergsona.  Krakow,  Ge- 
bethner,  191 1.*  308b 

Reprinted  from  Krytaka. 

Delvolve.  L'influence  de  la  philosophie  de  M.  Bergson.  I. 
Mouvement  socialiste,  29  1267-68,  April  191 1.  3°9 

Desaymard,  J.  Bergson  a  Clermond-Ferrand.  Bulletin  his- 
torique  et  scientifique  de  VAuvergne,  1910-1911:  204-16, 
243-67.*  3io 

Draghicesco,  D.  L'influence  de  la  philosophie  de  M.  Bergson. 
V.     Mouvement  socialiste,  30:266-69,  November  191 1.    311 

Flournoy,  Th.  La  philosophie  de  William  James.  Paris,  Saint- 
Blaise,  1911.*  312 

Fouillee,  Alfred.  L'influence  de  la  philosophie  de  M.  Bergson. 
II.  Mouvement  socialiste,  29  :  269,  April  191 1.  3X3 

Fouillee,  Alfred.  La  pensee  et  les  nouvelles  ecoles  anti-intellect- 
ualistes.     2e  edition.     Paris,  Felix  Alcan,  191 1.     xvi,  415  p. 

314 

Gillouin,  Rene.  La  philosophie  de  M.  Bergson.  Parthenon, 
20  October  191 1.*  3J5 

Gillouin,  Rene.  La  philosophie  de  M.  Henri  Bergson.  Revue  de 
Paris,  annee  18,  5  :  528-58,  847-75,  1-15  October  191 1.  316 

Gillouin,  Rene.     La  philosophie  de  M.  Bergson.     Paris,  Gras 
1911.  317 

Reprint,  in  the  main,  of  the  articles  in  the  Revue  de  Paris. 

35 


Gould,  F.  J.  Bergson  and  Balfour.  Literary  guide  and  ration- 
alist review,  n.  s.,  no.  185:  163-64,  1  November  191 1.      318 

Grivet,  Jules.  La  th£orie  de  la  personne  d'apres  Henri  Bergson. 
Etudes  par  des  peres  de  la  Compagnie  de  Jesus,  129  :  449-85, 
20  November  191 1.  3I9 

Hicks,  G.  Dawes.  Survey  of  recent  philosophical  and  theological 
literature.  Philosophy.  Hibbert  journal,  10  :  477-88,  Jan- 
uary 191 1.  320 
Recent  Bergson  literature,  p.  479-80. 

Hoppenot,  Henri.  Le  cours  de  M.  Bergson.  Bulletin  de  la 
semaine,  8  February  191 1.*  321 

Jacks,  L.  P.     Alchemy  of  thought.     New  York,  Holt,  191 1 .    322 

Jacks,  L.  P.  William  James  and  his  message.  Contemporary 
review,  99  120-23,  January  191 1.  323 

Jacobson,  Malte.  Henri  Bergsons  intuitions  filosofi.  Lund, 
191 1.     40  p.*  324 

Johnson,  F.  H.  God  in  evolution.  A  pragmatic  study  of  the- 
ology. Longmans,  191 1.*  325 
Reviewed  in:  Church  quarterly  review:  75: 185-86,  October  191 2. 

Joussain,  Andre.  Edouard  Schure  et  la  renaissance  de  l'idealisme 
romantique.  Revue  politique  et  litter  aire ,  Revue  bleue,  1  July 
1911   :2i-i6.  326 

Joussain,  Andre.  L'idee  de  l'inconscient  et  Tintuition  de  la  vie. 
Revue  philosophique,  71 1467-93,  May  191 1.  327 

Bergson,  p.  487-89. 

Landquist,  John.  Henri  Bergson.  Revue  scandinave,  October 
1911.*  328 

Landquist,  John.    Henri  Bergson.    Ord  och  bild,  191 1 ,  p. 541-550.* 

329 

Lasserre,  Pierre.  La  philosophic  de  M.  Bergson.  U action 
francaise,   15  March  191 1.*  33° 

36- 


Latest  of  philosophers.  Three  works  which  have  given  Berg- 
son  wide  repute  among  the  world  thinkers.  N.  Y.  Times 
review  of  books,  16  :  503,  20  August  191 1.  331 

Review  of:  Time  and  free  will;  Matter  and  memory;  Creative  evolution. 

Legendre,  Maurice.  L'influence  de  la  philosophic  de  M.  Berg- 
son.  IV.  Mouvement  socialiste,  30  :  120-23,  July-August 
1911.  332 

Levi,  Adolf o.  La  filosofia  dell  'intuizione  indiflerenziata  (H. 
Bergson — W.  James).  Rivista  di  psicologia  applicata,  7  : 
47-75,  January-February   191 1.  333 

Lindsay,  Alexander  Dunlap.  The  philosophy  of  Bergson. 
London,  J.  M.  Dent  &  sons,  Ltd.,  191 1.     ix,  247  p.  334 

Also  published  with  the  imprint  of  Hodder  &  Stoughton,  London,  and 
George  H.  Doran  Co.,  New  York. 

Lovejoy,  Arthur  O.  Schopenhauer  as  an  evolutionist.  Monist, 
21 :  195-222,  April  191 1.  335 

McCabe,  Joseph.  The  anti-rationalism  of  Bergson.  Literary 
guide  and  rationalist  review,  n.  s.,  no.  184  :  147-49,  October 
1911.  336 

McDougall,  William.  Body  and  mind,  a  history  and  a  defense 
of  animism.  London,  Methuen;  New  York,  The  Macmillan 
co.,  191 1.     xix,  384  p.  337 

Maritain,  Jacques.  L'evolutionnisme  de  M.  Bergson.  Revue 
de  philosophic,  19  1467-540,  September-October  191 1.  338 

Mason,  J.  W.  T.  Professor  Bergson's  principle  [Letter  to  the 
editor].     Nation,  93  :  31,  13  July  -1911.  339 

Criticism  of  a  review  of  Matter  and  memory. 

Mr.    Balfour's    objection    to    Bergson's    philosophy.      Cur 

literature,  51  1659-61,  December  1911.  340 

M.  Bergson  and  others.      Spectator,  106  1689-90,  6  May  191 1. 

341 

Review  of  various   philosophical   works,   including   Bergson's    Creative 
evolution  and  Matter  and  memory. 

37 


M.  Bergson  et  le  caractere  quotidien  de  la  philosophic  Spec- 
tateur,  December  191 1.*  342 

Muirhead,  J.  H.  The  philosophy  of  Bergson.  Hibbert  journal, 
9  1895-907,  July  191 1.  343 

Reviews  of  Time  and  free  will;  Matter  and  memory;  Creative  evolution. 

Muller,  Jean.  H.  Bergson,  philosophe  d'une  renaissance,  ou, 
Ce  que  nous  devons  a  Bergson.  Renaissance  contemporaine, 
24  April  191 1.*  344 

New  conception  of  God  as  creative  evolution.  Current  literature, 
51  :  182-83,  August  191 1.  345 

Palante,  Georges.  L'influence  de  la  philosophic  de  M.  Bergson, 
III.     Mouvement  socialiste,  29  :  270-71,  April  191 1.  346 

Perry,  Ralph  Barton.  Notes  on  the  philosophy  of  Henri  Bergson, 
I.  Anti-intellectualism  and  ininiediatism.  Journal  of  phi- 
losophy, psychology,  and  scientific  methods,  8  :  673-82,  7 
December  191 1.  347 

Philosophie  de  Bergson.     Revue  de  la  solidarity,  July  191 1.*    348 

Posizione  del  Bergson  di  fronte  agli  studi  psichici.  Luce  e 
ombra,  1911.*  349 

Rey,  Abel.  Le  congres  international  de  philosophie,  Bologne, 
6-1 1  Avril  191 1.     Revue  philosophique,  72  :  1-22,  July  191 1. 

350 

Contains  a  review  of  Bergson's  address. 

Roosevelt,  Theodore.  The  search  for  truth  in  a  reverend  spirit. 
Outlook,  99:819-26,  2  December  1911.  351 

Review  of  various  philosophical  works,  including  Creative  evolution  and 
Time  and  free  will. 

Rougue,  A.  Le  IVe  congres  international  de  philosophie. 
Voprossi  filossofii  i  psychogii,  191 1.*  352 

Schnippenkotter,  J.  Henri  Bergson  und  seine  philosophie. 
Akademische  monatsblatter,  jalir^.  23:  170,  191 1.*  353 

38 


Severac,  J.  B.     Enqnfctes:    Influence  de  la  philosophic  de  M. 
Bergson.     Mouoement  social  isle,  29  :  182-83,  March  1911. 

354 

Slosson,  Edwin  E.     Twelve  major  prophets  of  to-day — II :  Henri 

Bergson,  il.  por.  Independent,  70:  1246-61,  8  June  191 1.     355 

Bibliographic  notes,  p.   1260-61.     Includes  a  brief  bibliography  and  a 

final  section,  "How  to  read  Bergson." 

Solomon,  Joseph.     Creative  evolution,  by  Henri  Bergson  [Re- 
view].    Mind,  n.  s.  20  :  432~33>  July  I9"«  356 

Solomon,  Joseph.  Bergson.  London,  Constable  &  co.,  191 1. 
128  p.     (Philosophies,  ancient  and  modern).  357 

Books  useful  to  the  English  student  of  Bergson,  p.  128. 

Solomon,  Joseph.  The  philosophy  of  Bergson.  Mind,  n.  s. 
20  :  15-40,  January  191 1.  35° 

Solomon,  Joseph.  The  philosophy  of  Bergson.  Fortnightly 
review,  96  :  10 14-31,  1  November  191 1.  359 

Stewart,  John  McKellar.  A  critical  exposition  of  Bergson's  phil- 
osophy. London,  Macmillan  &  co.,  Ltd.,  191 1 .  3°4  P-  360 
Reviewed  in  :  Philosophical  review,  21:598-602,  September,  191 1  (E.  B. 
McGilvary). 

Successo  di  Enrico  Bergson.  Revista  di  filosofia  neoscholastica, 
3:  614-30,  December  191 1.*  3<>i 

T.,  J.  A.     Biological  philosophy.     Creative  evolution, 

by  Prof.   H.   Bergson.     Authorized  translation  by  Dr.  A. 
Mitchell  [Review].     Nature,  87  :  475~77,  12  October  191 1. 

362 

Taylor,  A.  E.  Matter  and  memory,  Henri  Bergson.  Authorized 
translation  by  N.  M.  Paul  and  W.  S.  Palmer  [Review]. 
International  journal  of  ethics,  22  :  101-07,  October  191 1. 

363 

[Uber  die  gegenwartige  aufgabe  der  philosophic].    Logos,  2  :  126- 

127,1911.  364 

Review  of  an  address  by  Henri  Bergson  at  the  4th  international  congress 

of  philosophy  at  Bologna. 

39 


Visan,  Tancrede  de.  L'attitude  du  lyrisme  contemporain. 
Paris,  Mercure  de  France,  191 1.     476  p.*  365 

Visan,  Tancrede  de.  Kant:  Choix  de  textes,  notice  par  Rene 
Gillouin;  H.  Bergson,  Choix  de  textes,  notice  par  Rene 
Gillouin  [Analyse].  Revue  de  philosophie,  18  :  101-02,  Jan- 
uary 191 1.  366 

Walker,  Leslie  J.  L'evolutionnisme  dans  la  theorie  de  la  connais- 
sance  et  de  la  verite.  Revue  de  philosophie,  19  :  417-66, 
September-October  191 1.  367 

Ward,  James.  The  realms  of  ends.  Cambridge  university 
press,  191 1.  368 

Bergson,  p.  306-307. 

Wize,  K.  F.  Der  vierte  kongress  fur  philosophie  in  Bologna. 
Vierteljahrsschrift  fur    wissenschaftliche    philosophie,     35  : 

459-483,  191 1.  369 

Bergson,  p.  464-66. 

Wolf,  A.  Philosophy  of  Bergson.  Jewish  review,  2:  204-33, 
September  191 1.  370 

1912 

Babbitt,  Irving.  Bergson  and  Rousseau.  Nation  (N.  Y.),  95: 
452~55>  14  November  1912.  371 

Babbitt,  Irving.  Bergson  et  Rousseau  (traduction  de  Jeanne 
Scialtiel).  Revue  politique  et  litteraire,  Revue  bleue,  50. 
annee,  2.  sem.   1725-30,  7  December  1912.  372 

Baeumker,  CI.  Ueber  die  philosophie  von  Henri  Bergson. 
Philosophisches  jahrbuch  der  Gorres-Gesellschaft,  25  :  1-23, 
Fulda,  191 2.  373 

Balsillie,  David.  An  examination  of  Professor  Bergson's  philoso- 
phy, London,  Williams  &  Norgate,  191 2.    xii,  228  p.    374 

Chapter  I,  Time  and  free  will,  reprinted  from  Mind,  April  1912.  Re- 
viewed in:  Church  quarterly  review,  74:126-42,  April  1912  (William  Brown) ; 
Revue  de  metaphysique,  20:  suppl.:25,  July  1912. 

40. 


Benda,  Julien.  Le  Bcrgsonismc,  ou  une  philosophic  dc  la 
mobility.     Paris,  Mercure  dc  France,  191 2.*  375 

Reviewed  in:  Nouvelle  revue,  ser.  4,  3  :  142,  September  1912. 

Bergson  and  Balfour  discuss  philosophy.  Review  of  reviews, 
45  :  107-08,  January  1912.  37^ 

Bergson  on  comedy  [Review  of  laughter].  Living  age,  272  : 
315-17,  3  February  1912.  377 

Berrod,  P.  La  philosophic  de  l'intuition.  Revue  philosophique, 
74  :  283-289,  September  191 2.  378 

Blacklock,  W.  Bergson's  Creative  evolution.  Westminster 
review,  177  :  343-347,  March  191 2.  379 

Bode,  B.  H.  Creative  evolution  by  Henri  Bergson,  translated 
by  A.  Mitchell  [Review].  American  journal  of  psychology, 
23  :  333-35,  April  1912.  380 

Bourdeau,  J.     La  philosophic  affective.  Paris,  Felix  Alcan,  1912.* 

381 

Brehier,  Emile.  La  philosophic  de  Henri  Bergson.  Conference 
donnee  k  l'Universite  d'Oviedo,  le  28  mars,  191 2.  Revue 
hebdomadaire  des  cours  et  conferences,  p.  337-46,  2  May, 
1912.*  382 

Brown,  William.  The  philosophy  of  Bergson,  Church  quarterly 
review,  74  :  126-42  April  191 2.  383 

Review  of:  Time  and  free  will,  Matter  and  memory,  Creative  evolution, 
Stewart's  Critical  exposition  of  Bergson's  philosophy.  Balsillie's  An  ex- 
amination of  Professor  Bergson's  philosophy. 

Calcagno,  Alberto.  Henri  Bergson  e  la  cultura  contemporanea. 
Rivista  difilosofia,  4:407-31,  July-October  1912.  384 

Calkins,  Mary  Whiton.  Henri  Bergson,  personalist.  Philosoph- 
ical review.     21 :  666-75,  November  1 91 2.  385 

Carlile,  William  W.  Perception  and  intersubjective  intercourse. 
Mind,  n.  s.  21  :  508-521,  October  191 2.  386 

Bergson,  p.  513. 

41 


Carr,  H.  Wildon.  Henri  Bergson:  The  philosophy  of  change. 
London,  T.  C.  and  E.  C.  Jack,  191 2.  91  p.  (The  people's 
books).  387 

Reviewed  in  Revue  de  metaphysique,  20  :  24,  July  1912. 

Carr,  H.  Wildon.  Modern  science  and  the  illusions  of  Professor 
Bergson.  By  Hugh  S.  R.  Elliot  [Review].  Mind,  n.  s. 
21  •  579_8i,  October  191 2.  388 

Carr,  H.  Wildon.  Henri  Bergson:  The  philosophy  of  change 
[Revue  critique].  Revue  de  metaphysique  et  de  morale, 
2o:suppl.:  24,  Jury  1912.  389 

Carus,  Paul.  The  anti-intellectual  movement  of  to-day.  Mon- 
ist,  22:397-404,  July  1912.  390 

Creative  evolution  and  the  philosophic  doubt,  by  Arthur  J. 
Balfour,  in  Hibbert  journal,  10  :  1-23,  October  191 1 
[Review].  Revue  de  metaphysique  et  de  morale,  20  :  27, 
July  1912.  391 

Critical  exposition  of  Bergson's  philosophy  by  J.  M.  K.  Stewart 
[Review].  London  quarterly  review,  117  :  358-359,  April 
1912.  392 

Dauriac,  Lionel.  Quelques  reflexions  sur  la  philosophic  de  M. 
Henri  Bergson.     Annee  philosophique,  1911,  22  :  55-72,  1912. 

393 

David,  J.  Wf.  Okofo  Bergsonismu.  Krytaka,  p.  344-53,  June 
1912;  p.  1-10,  99-1 1 1,  181-89,  239-52,  311-26,  July- 
December  19 12.  394 

De  Laguna,  Theodore.  La  pensee  et  les  nouvelles  ecoles  anti- 
intellectualistes.  Alfred  Fouillee  [Review].  Journal  of 
philosophy,  psychology,  and  scientific  methods,  9  :  498-500, 
29  August  191 2.  395 

Desaymard,  Joseph.  La  pensee  d'Henri  Bergson.  Paris,  Mecure 
de  France,  1912.     (Les  hommes  et  les  idees,  no.  25.)*  396 

42* 


Dewey,  John.  Perception  and  organic  action.  Journal  of 
philosophy,  psychology,  and  scientific  methods,  9:645-68, 
November  191 2.  397 

Dolson,  Grace  Neal.     De    Kant    a    Bergson,  par    C.  C 

[Review].     Philosophical  review,  21  :  380-1.   May   1912.398 

Dumesnil,  G.  Lasophistiquecontemporaine.  Amitie  de  France, 
February,  May.  August  1912.*  399 

Durban,  Wiiliam.     The  philosophy  of  Henry  Bergson.     Hon 
letic  review,  63:20-23,  January  1912.  4°° 

Dwelshauvers,  Georges.  Evolution  et  duree  dans  la  philosophic 
de  Bergson.  Revue  de  VUniversite  de  Bruxelles,  18:21-66, 
October  191 2.  401 

Eisler,  Rudolf.  Philosophen-lexikon.  Berlin,  Siegfried  Mutter 
und  Sohn,  1912.  4°2 

Bergson,  p.  57-60,  including  brief  bibliography. 

Elliot,  Hugh  S.  R.  Modern  science  and  the  illusions  of  Professor 
Bergson;  by  Hugh  S.  R.  Elliot,  with  preface  by  Sir  Ray 
Lankester.     London,  Longmans,  Green  &co.,  1912.         403 

Reviewed  in:  Mind,  21:579-81,  October  1912  (H.  W.  Carr). 

Ewald,  Oscar.  Philosophy  in  Germany  in  191 1 .  translated  from 
the  German  by  Prof.  Wm.  A.  Hammond.  Philosophical 
review,  21  :  499-526,  September  191 2.  404 

Bergson,  p.  523-525. 

Examination  of  Professor  Bergson's  philosophy.  By  David 
Balsillie  [Review].  Revue  de  metaphysique  et  de  morale, 
20  :suppl.:   25,  July  1912.  4°5 

Farges,  A.  La  notion  bergsonienne  du  temps.  Revue  neo- 
scholastique  de  philosophic,  I9:337"78»  I9*2*  4°6 

Fawcett,  Edward  Douglas.  Matter  and  memory.  Mind,  21  : 
201-232,  April  1912.  4-07 

43 


Gagnebin,  S.  La  philosophie  de  l'intuition.  Essai  sur  les 
idees  de  M.  Edouard  LeRoy,  240  p.  St.  Blaise,  Foyer 
solidariste,  191 2.*  4°8 

First  third  of  the  book  is  devoted  to  the  philosophy  of  Bergson.     Re- 
viewed in:   Revue  de  philosophie,  12  :  205-07,  7  August  19 12. 

Gaultier,  Paul.  L'ceuvre  philosophique  de  M.  Emile  Boutroux. 
Revue  des  deux  mondes,  6.  period;  11  :  837-71,  15  October 
1912.  409 

Gaultier,  Paul.  La  pensee  contemporaine.  Paris,  Hachette, 
1912.*  410 

Reviewed  in  Correspondant,  p.  793-98,  25  November  1912. 

Gillouin,  Rene.  L'influence  de  la  philosophie  de  M.  Bergson, 
VII.  Mouvement  socialiste,  31:  132-33,  February  1912.  411 

Goblot,  E.  A  propos  de  la  philosophie  de  Bergson.  Le  volume, 
18  May  1912.*  412 

Goetz,  Philip  Becker.  Bergson  [a  poem].  Open  court,  26  :  572, 
September  191 2.  413 

Guy-Grand,  Georges.  Un  philosophe  de  la  vie.  La  vie,  4  May 
1912.*  414 

Hebert,  Marcel.  M.  Bergson  et  son  affirmation  de  l'existence 
de  Dieu.  Revue  de  VUniversite  de  Bruxelles,  17:609-16, 
May-June  1912.  415 

Hermann,    E.     Eucken    and    Bergson,    their    significance    for 

Christian  thought.      London,  James   Clarke  &  co.,    191 2. 

224  p.  416 

Chapter  IV,  "Henri  Bergson  and  his  philosophy  of  creative  evolution," 
p.  127-79. 

Hermit  of  Prague,  pseud.  Modern  science  and  the  illusions  of 
Professor  Bergson,  by  Hugh  S.  R.  Elliot  [Review].  Bedrock, 
1   :  277-80,  July  1912.  417 

Heymans,  G.  De  philosophie  van  Henri  Bergson,  Tijdschrijt  v. 
wijsbeg,  no.  2  1205-28,  1912.*  418 

44  * 


Hicks,  G.  Dawes.  Survey  of  recent  philosophical  and  theological 
literature:  Philosophy.  Hibbert  journal,  10  :  477~88'  Jan_ 
uary  1912.  4*9 

Bergson,  p.  477-80. 

Hocking,  William  Ernest.  Meaning  of  God  in  human  experi- 
ence.    New  Haven,  Yale  University  Press,  1912.*  420 

Hookhan,  George.  Professor  Bergson  as  critic  of  Darwin. 
National  review,  59  :  101-18,  March  1912.  421 

Hookhan,  George.  Further  notes  on  Professor  Bergson's  philo- 
sophy.    National  review,  59  :  325~36>  April  191 2.  422 

Hunt,  Harriet  E.  The  psychology  of  auto-education,  based  on 
the  interpretation  of  intellect  given  by  Henri  Bergson  in  his 
"Creative  evolution."  Illustrated  in  the  work  of  Maria 
Montessori.     Syracuse,  N.  Y.,  C.  W.  Bardeen,  1912.     82  p.* 

423 

Husband,  Mary  Gilliland.  devolution  creatrice  par  Henri 
Bergson  [Review].  International  journal  of  ethics,  22  :  462- 
67,  July  191 2.  424 

Is  the  Bergson  philosophy  that  of  a  charlatan?  Current  litera- 
ture, 52  :  198-99,  February  191 2.  425 

Jacoby,  Giinther.  Henri  Bergson,  pragmatism  and  Schopen- 
hauer.    Monist,  22  :  593-611,  October  1912.  426 

Jordan,  Bruno.  Kant  and  Bergson.  Translated  from  the  German 
by  Lydia  Robinson.     Monist,  22  1404-14,  July  1912.    427 

Jourdain,  Philip  E.  B.  Logic,  M.  Bergson  and  Mr.  H.  G.  Wells. 
Hibbert  journal,  10  :  835-45,  July  191 2.  428 

Joussain,  Andre.  Samuel  Gagnebin:  La  philosophic  de  l'intui- 
tion.  Essai  sur  les  idees  dc  M.  Edouard  Le  Roy  [Revue 
critique].     Revue  philosophique,  74  :  I9I"I93,  August  191 2. 

429 

Joussain,  Andre.  L'expansion  du  Bergsonisme  et  la  psychologie 
musicale.  Revue  politique  et  litteraire,  Revue  bleue,  50.  annee, 
I.  sem.  1758-763,  15  June  1912.  43<> 

45 


Kallen,  H.  M.  Laughter :  an  essay  on  the  meaning  of  the  comic. 
H.  Bergson  [Review].  Journal  of  philosophy,  psychology, 
and  scientific  methods,  9 :  303-05,  23  May  191 2.  431 

Laughter:  Edinburgh  review,  215  1383-404,  April  1912.  432 

Review  of  five  books  on  the  subject.     Bergson,  p.  392-97. 

Laughter:  an  essay  on  the  meaning  of  the  comic.  By  Henri 
Bergson  [Review].  North  American  review,  195  1859-61, 
June  1 91 2.  433 

Le  Dantec,  Felix.  Contre  la  metaphysique.  Question  de 
met  node.     Paris,  Felix  Alcan,  1912.*  434 

Lenoble,  E.    Bergson.     Revue  du  clergefrancais,  15  March  191 2.* 

435 

LeRoy,  Edouard.  A  propos  de  l'intuition  bergsonienne.  Revue 
du  mois,  June  1912.  436 

LeRoy,  Edouard.  Une  philosophic  nouvelle:  M.  Henri  Bergson. 
I.  Lamethode;  II.  La  doctrine.  Revue  des  deux  mondes, 
6.  Per.,  7:  551-80,  800-33,  1  February  191 2,  15  February 
1912.  437 

LeRoy,  Edouard.  Une  philosophic  nouvelle:  Henri  Bergson. 
Paris,  Felix  Alcan,  191 2.*  438 

Libby,  Melanchthon,  F.  The  continuity  of  Bergson's  thought. 
University  of  Colorado  Studies,  9:147-202  (no.  4),  Septem- 
ber 1912.  439 

Lippman,    Walter.     Bergson's   philosophy.      New    York    Times 

Review  of  Books,  p.  665-66,  17  November  1912.  440 

Review    of    An    introduction    to    metaphysics.     By    Henri    Bergson. 
Putnam,  1912. 

Lippman,  Walter.  The  most  dangerous  man  in  the  world. 
Everybody' s  magazine,  27:   100-01,  July  1912.  441 

Lodge,  Sir  Oliver.  Balfour  and  Bergson.  Hibbert  journal, 
10  :  290-307,  January  191 2.  442 

Lodge,  Sir  Oliver.  Bergson's  intuitional  philosophy  justified. 
Current  literature,  52  .-443-45,  April  1912.  443 

46* 


Lovejoy,  Arthur  O.  The  problem  of  time  in  recent  French 
philosophy.      I.  Renouvier  and    recent  temporalism;   II. 

Tcmporalism  and  anti-intellectualism:  Bergson.  III.  Time 
and  continuity  :  Pillon,  James.  Philosophical  review,  21  : 
10-31,  322-43,  527-45-  January,  May,  September  1912.     444 

Low,  Sidney.  Mr.  Balfour  in  the  study.  Edinburgh  review, 
216:  257-78,  October  1912.  445 

Bergson,  p.  268-71. 

McGilvary,  Evander  Bradley.  Philosophy  of  Bergson,  by  A.  D. 
Lindsay;  Critical  exposition  of  Bergson's  philosophy,  by 
J.  McK.  Stewart  [Review].  Philosophical  review,  21: 
598-602,   September    1912.  44^ 

Marcel,  Gabriel.  Les  conditions  dialectiques  de  la  philosophic 
de  l'intuition.  Revue  de  metaphysique  et  de  morale,  20: 
638-52,  September  19 12.  447 

Maritain,  J.  Les  deux  bergsonismes.  Revue  thomiste,  20:433- 
50,  July-August  1 912.  448 

Martin,  S.  A.  Bergson:  Creative  evolution.  Princeton  theo- 
logical review.     10:  11 6-1 8,  January  191 2.  449 

Mayer,  Willy,  liber  Storungen  des  "wiedererkennens."  Eine 
kritische  untersuchung  im  anschluss  an  "Matiere  et  me- 
moire"  von  Henri  Bergson.  Zeitschrift  fur  patho  psychologic 
1  :  603-39,  May  1912.  450 

Contents : 

1.  Bergson's  Wahrnehmungs-  und  gedachtnistheorie. 

2.  Kritik  der  Bergsonscher  beweismaterials. 

3.  Versuch  der  nachpriisung  an  eigenen  beobachtungen. 

4.  Zusammenfassung  und  schluss. 

Meredith,  J.  C.  Critical  side  of  Bergson's  philosophy.  West- 
minster review ,  177:   194-206,  February  1912.  451 

Meyerson,  Emile.  Identite  et  realite.  2d  edition.  Paris, 
Felix  Alcan,  1912.  242  p.  (Bibliotheque  de  philosophic 
contemporaine.)  452 

47 


Modern  science  and  the  illusions  of  Professor  Bergson.  By- 
Hugh  S.  R.  Elliot  [Review].  Contemporary  review,  101  : 
905-906,  June  1912.  453 

Moore,  A.  W.  Bergson  and  pragmatism.  Philosophical  review, 
21:397-414,  July  1912.  454 

Moore,  Charles  L.  The  return  of  the  gods.  Dial,  53:371-72, 
16  November  1912.  455 

Morgan,  C.  Lloyd.  Instinct  and  experience.  London,  Methuen, 
1912.*  456 

Mories,  A.  S.  Bergson  and  mysticism.  Westminster  review, 
177  :  687-89,  June  1912.  457 

Miiller,  Ernst.  Henri  Bergson.  Archiv  filr  systematische 
philosophie,  18:   185-94,  May  1912.  458 

Neve,  Paul.  Le  pragmatisme  et  la  philosophie  de  M.  Bergson. 
Annates  de  VInstitut  superieur  de  philosophie  de  Louvain 
1  : 173-210,  1912.*  459 

Neve,  Paul.  Le  pragmatisme  et  la  philosophie  de  M.  Bergson, 
par  Paul  Neve,  charge  de  cours  a  1' University  de  Liege. 
Louvain,  Institut  supeYieur  de  philosophie,  1 91 2.    38p.*    460 

Overstreet,    Harry   Allen.      Mind    and    body.      Psychological 

bulletin,  9:13-20,  15  January  1912.  461 

Peleger,  Andre.     Le  bergsonisme  en  pratique.     Le  penseur,  April, 

June  1 9 1 2.*  462 

Perry,  Ralph  Barton.     Present  philosophical  tendencies.     New 

York,  Longmans,  Green  &  co.,  19 12.  463 

Poulton,  E.  B.     Darwin  and  Bergson  on  the  interpretation  of 

evolution.     Bedrock,  1:48-65,  April  1912.  464 

Prager,  Hans.     Schriften  von  Henri  Bergson.     Zeitschrift  filr 

philosophie   und   philosophische    kritik,     145:88-93,     1912. 

465 

Reviews  of:  Materie  und  geddchtnis;  Einfilhrung  in  die  metaphysik;  Zeit 
undfreiheit;  La  perception  du  changement;  Coignet,  De  Kant  d  Bergson. 

48     • 


Professor  Bergson  on  the  soul.  Educational  review,  43:  1-16, 
January  191 2.  4°6 

Summary  of  four  lectures  at  the  University  of  London. 

Professor  Henri  Bergson.  Open  court,  26  :  272-74,  September 
191 2.     Portrait.  4^7 

Prout,  F.  R.  L'intuition  philosophique,  by  H.  Bergson.  Revue 
de  metaphysique,  XIX,  6 :  809-827  [Review].  Philosophical 
review,  21  1265,  March  1912.  468 

Robinson,  A.  The  philosophy  of  Bergson.  Churchman, 
(London),  March  1912.*  469 

Rosenberg,  Maximilian.  Die  erinnerungstauschungen  der  "red- 
uplizierenden  paramnesie  "  und  des  "  deja  vu, "  ihre  klinische 
differenzierung  und  ihre  psychologischen  beziehungen  zuein- 
ander.  Zeitschrift  fur  pathopsychologie,  1  :  561-602,  May 
1912.  470 

Roz,  Firmin.  La  pensee  contemporaine.  Le  correspondent,  p. 
793-98,  25  November  1912.  471 

Russell,  Bertrand.  The  philosophy  of  Bergson.  Monist,  22  : 
321-347,  July  1912.  472 

Russell,  John  E.  Bergson's  anti-intellectualism.  Journal  of 
philosophy,  psychology,  and  scientific  methods,  9:  129-131, 
29  February   1912.  473 

Discussion  of  Perry,  Notes  on  the  philosophy  of  Henri  Bergson,  Journal 
of  philosophy  8:  673-82. 

S.,  M.      Gagebin,   S.   La  philosophic  de  l'intuition: 

Essai  sur  les  idees  de  M.  Edouard  LeRoy.     Revue  de  philo- 
sophic, 12:  205-07,  1  August  191 2.  474 

Sanborn,  Alvan  F.  Henri  Bergson,  pronounced  "the  foremost 
thinker  of  France."  His  personality,  his  philosophy,  and  his 
influence.     Century,  85: 172-76,  December  19 12.     Portrait. 

475 
49 


Schoen,  H.  Heinrich  Bergsons  philosophische  anschauungen. 
Zeitschrift  fur  philosophic  und  philosophische  kritik,  145  : 
40-87,  February  191 2.  476 

Scott,  J.  W.  Pessimism  of  Bergson.  Hibbert  Journal,  n :  99- 
116,  October  1912.  477 

Segond,  J.  Les  antitheses  du  Bergsonisme.  Annates  de  philoso- 
phic chretienne,  p.  449-74,  August  1912.*  478 

Segond,  J.  L'intuition  bergsonienne.  Paris,  Felix  Alcan,  1912. 
(Bibliotheque  de  philosophic  contemporaine.)*  479 

Segur,  Nicolas.  Bergson  et  Bergsonisme.  La  revue,  98:  297- 
315,  1  October  1912.  480 

Steinilber,  E.  Essai  critique  sur  les  id£es  philosophiques  con- 
temporaines.  Edition  de  la  societe  d'etudes  philosophiques. 
Paris,  Gauthier,  1912.     xiv,  391  p.*  481 

Sypkens,  D.  De  evolutieleer  van  Henri  Bergson.  Theologisch 
tijdschrift,  v.  46,  nos.  1-2,  191 2.*  482 

Taylor,  A.  E.  Creative  evolution.  By  Henri  Bergson.  Trans- 
lated by  Arthur  Mitchell  [Review].  International  journal 
of  ethics,  22  1467-69,  July  1912.  483 

Titchener,  E.  B.  Laughter:  an  essay  on  the  meaning  of  the 
comic.  By  Henri  Bergson.  Translated  by  C.  Brereton 
and  F.  Rothwell  [Review].  American  journal  of  psychology 
23  :  146-47,  January  191 2.  484 

Tonquedec,  Joseph  de.  M.  Bergson,  est-il  moniste?  Etudes  par 
des  peres  de  la  Compagnie  de  Jesus,  130 :  506-16,  20  February 
1912.  485 

Summarized  in:  Revue  de  philosophie,  20:421,  April  1912. 

Townsend,  James  G.  Bergson  and  religion.  Monist,  22  :  392- 
97,  July  1912.  486 

Tuttle,  J.  R.  Life  and  consciousness.  Henri  Bergson  in 
Hibbert  journal,  11  :  24-44  [Review].  Philosophical  re- 
view, 21  :  125-26,  January   1912.  487 

50       - 


Tuttle,  J.  R.  Creative  evolution  and  the  philosophic  doubt,  by 
A.  J.  Balfour  in  Hibbert  Journal,  1 1  :  1-23  [Review].  Philo- 
sophical review,  21  :  122-23,  January  1912.  488 

Underhill,  Evelyn.  Bergson  and  the  mystics.  English  review, 
10  :  511-22,  February  1912.  Same  article  Living  age,  272  : 
668-75,  l6  March  191 2.  489 

Underhill,  Evelyn.  Mysticism,  a  study  in  the  nature  and  de- 
velopment of  man's  spiritual  consciousness,  New  York, 
E.  P.  Dutton,  191 2.     xv,  600  p.  490 

Bergson,  p.  31-36. 

Vettard,  Camille.  Le  Bergsonisme  ou  une  philosophic  de  la 
mobilite,  par  Julien  Benda  [Revue  critique].  Nouvelle  revue 
francaise,  4:940-44,  1  November  1912.  491 

Vietroff,  J.  L'influence  de  la  philosophic  de  M.  Bergson,  VI. 
Mouvement    socialiste,  31 :  62-64,  January  191 2.  492 

W.,  B.  C.  A.     Laughter,  translated  by  C.  Brereton  and  F. 

Rothwell    [Review].     Dublin    review,    151:    181-184,    July 
1912.  493 

Wahl,  Jean.  Deux  ouvrages  recents  sur  la  philosophic  de  M. 
Bergson.     Revue  du  mois,  7.  annee:  153-80,  August  1912. 

494 
Critical  discussion  of  Le  Bergsonisme  by  Julien  Benda,  and  Une 
philo sophie  nouvelle  by  Edouard  Le  Roy. 

Waterlow,  Sydney.  Philosophy  of  Bergson.  Quarterly  review, 
216  : 152-76,    January    1912.  495 

Wolf,  A.  Mr.  Balfour  on  teleology  and  creative  evolution. 
Hibbert  journal,  10  :  469-72,  January  191 2.  49° 

Discussion  of  article  in  Hibbert  journal,  October,  191 1. 


51 


INDEX 
References  are  to  entry  numbers  not  to  page  numbers. 


A  propos  d'un  article  de  Mr.  W.  B. 
,  Pitkin,  78 
A    proPos  de   revolution   de   Vintelli- 

gence  geometrique,  59 
Aimel,  Georges,  171 
Alexander,  S.,  99 
Antoniade,  C,  172,  248 
Ardigo,  Roberto,  173 

Babbitt,  Irving,  371,  372 
Babynin,  B.,  292 
Baeumker,  CI.,  373 
Baldwin,  James  Mark,  293 
Balfour,  Arthur  J.,  294 
Balsillie,  David,  295,  374 
Balthaser,  Nicholas,  154 
Batault,  Georges,  174 
Baylac,  Jacques,  216 
Becher,  Erich,  249 
Belot,  Gustave,  87,  100 
Benda,  Julien,  375 
Benrubi,  Isaak,  250,  251 
Berrod,  P.,  378 
Berthelot,  Rene,  155,  175 
Besse,  Clement,  156 

Binet,  A.,  123 

Bjorkman,  Edwin,  299,  300,  301 

Blacklock,  W.,  379 

Blum,  Eugene,  134 

Blum,  Jean,  149 

Bode,  B.  H.,  176,  380 

Boer,  T.  J.  de,  218 

Bon  sens  et  les  etudes  classiques,  7 

Bornhausen,  K.,  252 

Bosanquet,  Bernard,  253,  302 

Boucaud,  Charles,  135 

Bougle\  C.,  219 

Bourdeau,  J.,  381 

Boyd,  W.,  157 


Braun,  O.,  220 
Brehier,  Emile,  382 
Brown,  William,  383 
Brunschvicg,  Leon,  109,  140 

C,  J.,  115 

Calcagno,  Alberto,  384 

Calder6n,  F.  Garcia,  158 

Calkins,  Mary  Whiton,  385 

Cantecor,  G.,  130 

Carlile,  William  W.,  386 

Carr,  H.  Wildon,  221,  254,  255,  303, 
304,  387,  388,  389.  390 

Cams,  Paul,  391 

Ceresole,  P.,  141 

Chaumeix,  J.  H.  A.,  177,  222,  256 

Chide,  Alphonse,  178,  179,  223 

Choix  de  textes,  82 

Cockerell,  J.  D.  A.,  305 

Coignet,  C,  136,  306 

Constant,  Leonard,  137 

Corbiere,  Charles,  257 

Couchoud,  P.  L.,  124 

Courbes  respiratoires  pendant  V hyp- 
nose,  43 

Coutourat,  Louis,  95 

Creative  evolution,  55 

Crespi,  A.,  180 

Cristiani,  Leon,  181 

Dauriac,  Lionel,  no,  394 

David,  J.  W.,  308a,  308b,  395 

De  la  simulation  inconsciente,  3 

Decoster,  P.,  182 

De  Laguna,  Theodore,  396 

Delbos,  Victor,  101 

Delvolve\  309 

Desaymard,  Joseph,  310,  397 

Dewey,  John,  398 


53 


Dienes,  P.,  258 

Dienes,  V.,  258 

Dolson,  Grace  Neal,  259,  399 

Donnees  immediates  de  la  conscience, 

Essai  sur  les,  4 
Draghicesco,  D.,  311 
Driesch,  Hans,  183 
Dumesnil,  G.,  400 
Duprat,  E.,  184 
Duprat,  G.  L.,  159 
Durban,  William,  401 
Dwelshauvers,  Georges,  142,  160,  161, 

185,  402 

Effort  intellectuel,  21 
Einfuhrung  in  die  metaphysik,  25 
Eister,  Rudolf,  403 
Elliot,  Hugh  S.  R.,  404 
Eschbach,  V.,  260 
Esprit  et  matiere,  44 
Essai  sur  les  donnees  immediates  de 
f  la  conscience,  5 
Evolution  creatrice,  54 
Evolution    creatrice     (Reply     to    Le 

Dantec's  criticism),  58 
Ewald,  Oscar,  405 
Extraits  de  Lucrece,  2 

Farges,  Albert,  224,  225,  226,  407 

Fawcett,  Edward  Douglas,  408 

Ferrar,  W.  J.,  227 

Ferri,  Luigi,  88 

Filosofia  deir  intuizione,  introduzione 

alia  metafisica,  26 
Filosofien  och  livet,  85 
Florence,  Jean,  261 
Flournoy,  Th.,  312 
Fontana,  Paul,  162 
Fouillee,  Alfred,  96,  313,  314 
Fritzsche,  Richard,  262 

Gagnebin,  S.,  409 

Gardiner,  H.  N.,  97 

Garrigou-Lagrange,  Fr.,  228 

Gaultier,  Jules  de,  263 

Gaultier,  Paul,  410,  411 

Gebert,  K.,  186 

Giessler,  125,  131 

Gillouin,  Rene,   264,  315,  316,  317, 

412 
Goblot,  E.,  413 
Goetz,  Philip  Becker,  414 


Goldstein,  J.,  229 
Goldstein,  Julius,  265 
Gould,  F.  J.,  318 
Grivet,  Jules,  230,  319 
Grosse,  Ernst,  116 
Gurewitsch,  A.,  132 
Guy-Grand,  Georges,  415 

Hermann,  E.,  417 

Hermit  of  Prague,  pseud.,  418 

Herr,  Lucien,  89 

Heymans,  117 

Heymans,  G.,  419 

Hicks,  G.  Dawes,  320,  420 

Hocking,  William  Ernest,  421 

Hollard,  A.,  163 

Hookhan,  George,  422,  423 

Hoppenot,  Henri,  321 

Hulme,  T.  E.,  231,  232 

Hunt,  Harriet  E.,  424 

Husband,  Mary  Gilliland,  425 

Idee  de  neant,  51 

Inconscient  dan  la  vie  mentale,  75 
Influence    de    la    philosophie    de    M. 
Bergson,  309,  311,  313,  332,  346, 

354.  412 
Introduction  a  la  metaphysique,  24 
Introduction  to  a  new  philosophy,  30 
Introduction  to  metaphysics,  29 
Intuition  och  intelligence.     Inledning 

till  metafyseken,  28 
Intuition  philosophique,  85 

Jacks,  L.  P.,  322,  323 

Jacob,  B.,  106a 

Jacobson,  Malte,  324 

Jacoby,  Giinther,  267,  427 

James,  William,  233,  234,  268,  269 

James,    W.     Pragmatisme.     Intro- 
duction par  H.  Bergson,  81 

Janssens,  Edgar,  164 

Jeanniere,  Rene,  270 

Johnson,  F.  H.,  325 

Joel,  K.,  271 

Jourdain,  Philip  E.  B.,  429 

Jourdan,  Bruno,  428 

Joussain,  Andre,  272,  326,  327>F.43°» 
431 

Kallen,  H.  M.,  273,  432 
Keperling,  H.  von,  187 
Kodis,  J.,  188,  235 


54 


Kroner,  Richard,  274 

Lalande,  Andre\  150,  189 

Lanczi,  E.,  275 

Landormy,  P.,  118 

Landquist,  328,  329 

Lasserre,  Pierre,  330 

Lasson,  Adolf,  276 

Laughter,  17 

Lechalas,  G.,  90,102. 

Leclere,  Albert,  126,  236 

Le  Dantec,  Felix,  165,  190,  276a,  435 

Legendre,  Maurice,  191,  332 

Leighton,  J.  A.,  277 

Lenoble,  192 

Lenoble,  E.,  436 

LeRoy,  Edouard,  in,  437,  438-  439 

Levi,  Adolfo,  144,  333 

Levy-Bruhl,  L.,  91 

Libley,  Melanchthon,  F.,  440 

Life  and  consciousness,  83 

Lindsay,  Alexander  Dunlap,  334 

Lippmann,  Walter,  441,  442 

Lodge,  Sir  Oliver,  443,  444 

Loveday,  T.,  193 

Lovejoy,  A.  O.,  237,  335,  445 

Low,  Sidney,  446 

Lucrece,  Extraits  de,  2 

Luquet,  G.  H.,  151 

Lux,  Jacques,  152 

McCabe,  Joseph,  336 
MacDonald,  M.  S.,  127 
McDougall,  William,  337 
McGilvary,  Evander  B.,  447 
Marcel,  Gabriel,  448 
Margerie,  Amedil  de,  103 
Maritain,  Jacques,  338,  449 
Martin,  S.  A.,  450 
Masci,  Filippo,  108 
Mason,  J.  W.  T.,  339 
Mater ie  und  gedachtnis,  1 1 
Matiere  et  memoir e,  10 
Matter  and  memory,  12 
Mayer,  Willy,  451 
Memoire  et  reconnaissance,  8 
Meredith,  J.  C,  452 
Meyerson,  Emile,  453 
Mitchell,  A.,  194 
Moisant,  Xavier,  128,  145 
Momigliano,  Attilio,  238 
Mondain,  G.,  195 


Moore,  A.  W.,  455 
Moore,  Charles  L.,  456 
Morgan,  C.  Lloyd,  457 
Modes,  A.  S.,  458 
Morselli,  E.,  112 
Muirhead,  J.  H.,  343 
Muller,  A.,  278 
Miiller,  Ernst,  459 
Muller,  Jean,  344 
Muller-Freienfels,  Richard,  279 

Neve,  Paul,  460,  461 

Noel,  L.,  166 

Notes   sur  les  origines  psychologiques 

de  notre  croyance  a  la  loi  de   causa- 

lite,  18 
Notice  sur  la  vie  et  les  ceuvres  de  M. 

Felix  Ravaisson-Mollien,  37,  53 

Overstreet,  Harry  Allen,  462 

Palante,  Georges,  346 

Palmer,  William  Scott,  196,  239,  240 

Parallelisme     psycho-physique    et    la 

metaphysique  positive,  20 
Paralogisme  psycho-physiologique,  42 
Parodi,  D.,  119,  197 
Paulhan,  Fr.,  113 
Peleger,  Andre,  463 
Pegnes,  T.  M.,  198 
Perception  du  changement,  84 
Perception  et  matiere,  9 
Perry,  Ralph  Barton,  347 
Petrone,  Igino,  114, 
Piat,  Clodius,  199 
Pillon,  F.,  94,  104,  120,  200 
Pilszecker,  A.,  105 
Pitkin,  Walter  B.,  280 
Place  et  le  charactere  de  la  philosophic 

dans  V enseignement  secondaire,  31 
Poulton,  E.  B.,  465 
Pradines,  Maurice,  281 
Prager,  Hans,  282,  466 
Prezzolini,  Guiseppe,  38,  241,  283 
Prins,  Adolphe,  167 
Prout,  F.  R.,  469 

Quid  Aristoteles  de  loco  senserit,  3a 

Radiations,  N.,  36 

Rageot,  Gaston,  146,  147,  168,  201 

Rapport  sur  lafondation  Carnot,  23,  38 


55 


Rapport  sur  le  concours  pour  le  prix 

Bordin,  47,  52 
Rapport  sur  le  concours  pour  le  prix 

Le  Dissez  de  Penanrun,  67,  71 
Rapport  sur  le  concours  pour  le  prix 

Halphen,  32,  34 
Rauh,  F.,  106,  139 
Raymond,  P.,  242 
Reve,  Le,  19 
Revue  critique;  Principes  de  metaphy- 

sigue  par  Paul  Janet,  13 
Rey,  Abel,  350 
Rire,  Le,  14-15 
Robinson,  A.,  470 
Roosevelt,  Theodore,  351 
Rosenberg,  Maximilian,  471 
Ross,  G.  R.  T.,  202 
Ross,  G.  T.,  243 
Rougue,  A.,  352 
Royce,  Josiah,  285 
Roz,  Firmin,  472 
Russell,  Bertrand,  473 
Russell,  John  E.,  474 

Sanborn,  Alvan  F.,  476 
Sarlo,  F.  de,  121 
Sauvage,  George  M.,  153,  203 
Schnippenkotter,  J.,  353 
Schoen,  H.,  204,  477 
Schopferische  entwicklung,  57 
Scott,  J.  W.,  478 
Segond,  J.,  479,  480 
Segur,  Nicholas,  481 
Seilliere,  E.,  244 
Seliber,  G.,  245 
Severac,  J.  B.,  354 
Shepherd,  Queen  L.,  286 
Silberstein,  205 
Skapande  utvecklingen,  56 
Skrattet,  16 

Slosson,  Edwin  E.,  355 
Smith,  Norman,  206 
Sobieski,  Michal,  287 
Solomon,  Joseph,  356,  357,  358,  359 
Sorel,  Georges,  207 
Souvenir  du  present  et  la  fausse  re- 
connaissance, 70 


Speciality,  La,  1 

Steeg,  TM  129 

Steenbergen,  Albert,  246,  247 

Steinilber,  E.,  482 

Stewart,  John  McKellar,  360    - 

Stout,  G.  F.,  92 

Sur  V influence  de  sa  philosophie  sur 

les  Sieves  des  lycees,  60 
Sypkens,  D.,  483 

T.,  J.  A.,  362 

Tarde,  Introduction  et  pages  choisies, 

Preface  de  H.  Bergs  on,  74 
Tarozzi,  Giuseppe,  98  >" 

Taylor,  A.  E.,  363,  484 
Time  and  free  will,  5 
Titchenor,  E.  B.,  485 
Tonqu6dec,  Joseph  de,  169,  208,  209, 

210,  486 
Townsend,  James  G.,  487 
Trouche,  H.,  211 
Tufts,  J.  H.,  122 
Tuttle,  J.  R.,  488,  489 
Tyrrell,  G.,  212 

Underhill,  Evelyn,  490,  491 

Varisco,  B.,  148,  213 

Vettard,  Camille,  492 

Vi6troff,  J.,  493 

Villassere,  H.,  214 

Visan,  Tancrede  de,  291,  365,  366 

Vision  de  lueurs  dans  Vobscurite  par 

les  sensitifs,  35 
Volonte,  22 

W.,  B.  C.  A.,  494 
Walker,  Leslie  J.,  367 
Ward,  James,  368 
Waterlow,  Sydney,  495 
Weber,  Louis,  170 
Whittaker,  T.,  93 
Wize,  K.  F.,  369 
Wolf,  A.,  215,  370,  496 

Zeit  und  freiheit,  6 


56 


IVERSITY  OF  CALIFORNIA  LIBRARY, 
BERKELEY 


IS  BOOK  IS  DUE  ON  THE  LAST  DATE 

STAMPED  BELOW 

Books  not  returned  mi  time  are  subject  to  a   fine  of* 

p<  r  volume  after  the  third  day  overdue,  increasing 

.1.00  per  volume   after  the   Sixth   day.      Books   not  in 

land  may  be   renewed   if  application  is  made  before 

0   of   loan   period. 


■»14  .^N0V29J9869H 


DEC    &  1 


OCT  29 


LIBRARY  USE 

APR  4    1957 
REC'D  LD 

JUN3    1957 


INSTAOd 

NO/151965 


\m 


x  —  ~- 


jtt25'»-ttW| 


FEB  21  1968  8  0 


'%';: 


20m-ll,'20 


t  iL 


<&}>  Ml 

